A Tale Of Two Thunderbolt Storage Devices: Seagate's GoFlex Desk and Western Digital's Thunderbolt Duo
- Posted in
- Thunderbolt
- Seagate
- WD
- Western Digital
Between the two Seagate dock adapters, in combination with the interface allotment on the Mac mini, I had three different bus options available to me on the GoFlex Desk...
so I tested 'em all:
| Seagate GoFlex Desk Benchmark Results | ||
| Interface | AJA Write (MBytes/sec) | AJA Read (MBytes/sec) |
| USB 2 | 26.5 | 34.1 |
| FireWire 800 | 51.1 | 39.6 |
| Thunderbolt | 135.7 | 136.1 |
Recall my earlier comments, "Yet as anyone who's used a USB 2.0 hard drive or flash drive knows, the bus's read and write performance still leaves a lot to be desired, especially for video and other large-file-size material." I think that the results of this study justify that particular stance. FireWire 800 delivered speedier results, but not dramatically so, and this was the only case where writes were faster than reads (for unknown reasons).
Now take a look at the Thunderbolt results, and the rationalization for the interface become clear. Had I had an available eSATA port on both the drive and the system, I likely would have gotten similar data. However, as previously mentioned, eSATA's storage-only relevance led to modest-at-best adoption, and as such it wasn't a testing option in this particular setup. Note the slightly faster transfer speeds of the GoFlex Desk than with the single-disk and mirrored test configurations of the Thunderbolt Duo, likely reflective of the faster Seagate HDD rotational speed.
Anand had previously noted high operating temperatures under load when he tested the 3 TByte GoFlex Desk, and subsequently pointed out the improved airflow characteristics of the 4 TByte product's enclosure design in last year's follow-up review. My GoFlex Desk for Mac appears to leverage the latter enclosure design, and as such its operating temperature results were acceptable, particularly for a completely silent fanless design:
As an aside, although I was unable to run AJA System Test on my Mac mini's HDD for some unknown reason, here's what I got when I benchmarked the personally-upgraded SSD in my "Mid-2010" 13" MacBook Pro (Mac OS 10.6, 2.4 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, 8 GBytes 1067 MHz DDR3 SDRAM, Intel SSDSA2CW300G3 300 GByte SSD, TRIM Enabler activated):
| MacBook Pro Benchmark Results | ||
| Interface | AJA Write (MBytes/sec) | AJA Read (MBytes/sec) |
| 3 Gbps SATA | 171.7 | 264.8 |
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/5797/a-tale-of-two-thunderbolt-storage-devices-seagates-goflex-desk-and-western-digitals-thunderbolt-duo (Wayback Machine).

