A Tale Of Two Thunderbolt Storage Devices: Seagate's GoFlex Desk and Western Digital's Thunderbolt Duo
- Posted in
- Thunderbolt
- Seagate
- WD
- Western Digital
Given that the PCI Express channel of the Thunderbolt interface delivers 10 Gbps of peak bandwidth in either direction, I next decided to see what would happen if I tethered the Seagate and WD drives together.
Granted, Thunderbolt's 8b/10b encoding scheme reduced the effective peak bandwidth to 8 Gbps, i.e. 1 GByte/sec, but that's still substantially higher than the measured throughput of a single Thunderbolt Duo far from that of the Seagate GoFlex Desk. I ran my tests twice, in both cases with the WD Thunderbolt Duo in RAID 0 mode with 32KB RAID block size:
- With the WD drive's upper Thunderbolt port connected to the Mac mini, and the WD drive's lower port connected to the Seagate drive's upper port, and
- With the Seagate drive's upper Thunderbolt port connected to the Mac mini, and the Seagate drive's lower port connected to the WD drive's upper port
After installing a second iteration of AJA System Test, I fired up both copies of the program. Given that the measured transfer rate performance of the WD Thunderbolt Duo in RAID 0 mode was roughly twice that of the Seagate GoFlex Desk, I started the Seagate drive's write test first and, when it was roughly halfway done, got the WD drive going. That way, the two drives' write accesses overlapped for the second half of the Seagate write benchmark cycle, and their read accesses overlapped for the first half of the Seagate read benchmark cycle. Here's the result:
| Combined-Drive Benchmark Results (WD Thunderbolt Duo First In Chain) | ||
| Drive | AJA Write (MBytes/sec) | AJA Read (MBytes/sec) |
| WD Thunderbolt Duo | 239.5 | 241.5 |
| Seagate GoFlex Desk | 135.8 | 135.9 |
| Combined-Drive Benchmark Results (Seagate GoFlex Desk First In Chain) | ||
| Drive | AJA Write (MBytes/sec) | AJA Read (MBytes/sec) |
| WD Thunderbolt Duo | 239.6 | 241.6 |
| Seagate GoFlex Desk | 136.1 | 136.3 |
You can download and peruse the entire suite of test results for yourself, but the short-and-sweet summary is that I discerned no performance degradation from either drive when they were simultaneously doing write or read operations. It's one thing to do the math and conceptually convince yourself that something's possible; it's another thing entirely to see it happen right in front of your eyes. Impressive. Very impressive.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/5797/a-tale-of-two-thunderbolt-storage-devices-seagates-goflex-desk-and-western-digitals-thunderbolt-duo (Wayback Machine).
