Archive 1997–2024

A Tale Of Two Thunderbolt Storage Devices: Seagate's GoFlex Desk and Western Digital's Thunderbolt Duo

As previously mentioned, I relied on Disk Utility to handle my configuration of the Thunderbolt Duo, which enabled me to test both the full range of RAID block sizes and an additional configuration mode, concatenation. However, altering the RAID block size produced no discernable difference in the outcome, aside from minor variability that can otherwise be explained as normal run-to-run randomness:

WD Thunderbolt Duo Benchmark Results
Configuration mode AJA Write (MBytes/sec) AJA Read (MBytes/sec)
RAID 0 (16KB) 240.1 241.6
RAID 0 (32KB default) 239.3 241.5
RAID 0 (64KB) 239.6 241.5
RAID 0 (128KB) 239.5 241.1
RAID 0 (256KB) 240.4 241.4
RAID 1 (16KB) 120.0 122.4
(RAID 1 (32KB default) 119.8 121.5
RAID 1 (64KB) 119.1 122.5
(RAID 1 (128KB) 118.4 122.6
RAID 1 (256KB) 120.6 121.9
Concatenated 123.0 123.4
JBOD (A) 123.3 122.8
JBOD (B) 122.5 122.6

Not surprisingly, the RAID 0 striped results were roughly twice as fast than those either accessing a single drive at a time (JBOD and concatenated) or both drives simultaneously but in a mirrored fashion (RAID 1). Note that unlike with an elementary file copy test to or from another HDD or SSD, where the interface bandwidth limitations of the other drive might actually be the performance bottleneck, AJA System Test (like Iometer) generates data on-the-fly out of RAM.

Even after length and heavy access, and in spite of the Thunderbolt Duo's fanless design, both drives in the enclosure remained reasonably cool:

And the Thunderbolt Duo is also completely silent, save for the scant sounds of the drives themselves (further muffled by the enclosure surrounding them).

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/5797/a-tale-of-two-thunderbolt-storage-devices-seagates-goflex-desk-and-western-digitals-thunderbolt-duo (Wayback Machine).