Archive 1997–2024

A Tale Of Two Thunderbolt Storage Devices: Seagate's GoFlex Desk and Western Digital's Thunderbolt Duo

Speaking of the system, what am I using on this project? Not surprisingly, it's a Mac. Specifically, it's an "early 2011" Mac mini, running an up-to-date copy of Mac OS 10.7 "Lion" and containing a 2.3 GHz Intel Core i5-2415M CPU with dual physical cores along with the aforementioned HyperThreading support. It includes a Toshiba MK5065GSXF 500 GByte 2.5" HDD, and I've upgraded the system memory from the initial 2 GByte allocation to 8 GBytes of 1333 MHz DDR3 SDRAM:

I did all of my benchmarking using the free (and therefore commonly used and cited) AJA System Test, which generates both graphical and text-based results:

AJA System Test is admittedly not as feature-robust as Iometer; I can't, for example, precisely control variables such as data payload size, access profile characteristics (including starting and ending cluster counts), and the number of queued I/O requests. And in spite of the robust-sounding DiskWhackTest that runs when you specific a Disk Read/Write Test, as I did, the results suggest that it's doing only sequential reads and writes (which makes sense, given that the program was originally developed for video professionals).

Nonetheless, given that my predominant motivation was to test the peak performance potential of the HDD-plus-interface combination, not the random-access characteristics of the HDD itself, AJA System Test will do for now. In all cases, I specified a 1920x1080 pixel, 10-bit video frame size, along with a 16 GByte overall file size, and for perhaps obvious reasons I left the default enabled 'disable file system cache' setting as-is.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/5797/a-tale-of-two-thunderbolt-storage-devices-seagates-goflex-desk-and-western-digitals-thunderbolt-duo (Wayback Machine).