Archive 1997–2024

The Highest-End Notebooks, 2009

General Windows Performance

Quite a few people have asked for some general performance numbers in terms of Windows boot/shutdown, hibernate/resume, and sleep/wake times. These vary quite a bit between runs, depending on what you've been doing on the computer. If you have a bunch of open applications, it will take longer for the system to enter sleep mode for example. We performed these tests on these notebooks from an empty Windows desktop, and we used the best-case result for each system. As a side note, these tests benefit from a fast SSD, providing more consistent results and better times. However, as we will see, these desktop systems are all quite slow when it comes to booting up and shutting down -- or hibernating or sleeping even.

Windows System Performance

Windows System Performance

Windows System Performance

Windows System Performance

Windows System Performance

Windows System Performance

System Performance - POST

The results are a mixture of good and bad -- and keep in mind we are comparing these notebooks with relatively inexpensive laptops. The three notebooks place at the top in shutdown times, and they also do quite well in the hibernate test, but everywhere else they trail behind the ASUS netbook and Gateway laptops. In some of the tests, there's a huge difference -- like the extremely poor sleep and wake times. Keep in mind that the Gateway notebooks also have 4GB RAM, so outside of the 6GB D900F we're dealing with the same amount of memory.

What the OS performance charts don't tell you is that the boot and resume times are hugely influenced by POST times, so we added that chart. The ASUS netbook will POST in under two seconds, the Gateway notebooks take 7-8 seconds, and it only gets worse from there. The W870CU is the fastest of the high-end notebooks when it comes to POST time: 15.3 seconds. The Eurocom M980NU requires a lengthy 20.5 second POST, and at the back of the pack is the D900F: 26.5 seconds! We can cut the D900F a bit of slack since the RAID set adds an extra 7.5 seconds, but regardless of these notebooks could be dramatically improved in this area. The D900F takes almost as long to POST as it does to load the OS, while the POST times on the other two notebooks only account for one third of the boot time. Ugh.

This is one area where the simplicity of netbooks is truly a benefit, but there's no reason more complex notebooks can't POST a lot faster. We would like to set a goal for all notebook manufacturers: get your system to POST in at most 5 seconds and we will be content. If ASUS and other netbook manufacturers can achieve abbreviated POST times of less than 2 seconds, we don't think that's too much to ask.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2858/the-highest-end-notebooks-2009 (Wayback Machine).