HP w2408: A "New" Twist on 24" LCDs
- Posted in
- Displays
Closing Thoughts
Frankly, considering the price, it's difficult to justify the HP w2408. It looks nice and performs reasonably well, but there other similarly priced LCDs have better features and higher-quality panels. We like the idea of seeing 24" LCDs come down in price, but we would prefer to keep most of the features and quality intact. Dell's 2405FPW offered numerous video inputs back in 2005 with an S-PVA panel; while we might rate the modern S-TN panel used in the w2408 as being slightly better and the design is more attractive, in other ways the 2405FPW is still superior.
At the end of the day, we don't review products in a vacuum. Casual users would be more than happy running the HP w2408, and they might not care how it compares with other LCDs. We are working on getting additional display products reviewed, but the only major attraction of the w2408 seems to be the appearance/design. You get the basic features, a silly (at least in this reviewer's opinion) auto-brightness sensor, and that's about it.
Still, let's not discount the importance of appearance. People can spend thousands of dollars on office furniture, simply because they think it looks nicer or is more comfortable to use. If you just need a computer monitor and you think the w2408 looks great, go for it. If on the other hand you prefer more accurate colors, more video input options, and/or better viewing angles, there are definitely better 24" LCDs. HP's own LP2465 is one alternative, provided you can live without extra video inputs. You get a different stand and an S-PVA panel, all for a slightly slower price with the current $75 mail-in rebate (from Newegg). Another newer LCD is the Gateway FHD2400; like the w2408, it uses an S-TN panel, but it seems to offer better overall quality and many more input options.
If you want choice, there are presently over 25 different 24" LCDs listed at Newegg. You have everything from budget models looking to get into the sweet spot of $300 or less, up through many in the $600-$8700 range. The only difficulty now is figuring out which option is best; unfortunately, not one of the current 24" displays offers an S-IPS panel. If you're an LCD snob, the 30" panels are still they way to go, and luckily there will be some new options in that realms early next year.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2408 (Wayback Machine).