SSD Updates
We have been busily preparing a new storage test suite that features Vista Ultimate 64. Call us crazy for using Vista at this point, but in order to properly test new technologies like ReadyBoost, ReadyDrive, and Low-priority I/O, this meant a change to the latest (but not greatest) that Microsoft offers. This change, like most when moving to Vista, has not exactly been smooth. The loss of our Intel IPEAK test suite is one that stings, as it is not compatible with Vista, but we will still provide selected numbers when appropriate. However, we believe our final selection of benchmarks will be able to provide a well-rounded look at a storage device’s performance from an actual application viewpoint. We will still provide a select number of theoretical benchmarks but our emphasis will be on how the storage device performs in a variety of actual benchmarks ranging from gaming to database creation.
The drive manufacturers are currently busy offering second-generation hybrid and PMR based mechanical devices but the real news in storage technology continues to be the rapid developing SSD market. We provided an early first look at the latest generation SSD drive from MTRON and since then have been bombarded not only with requests for additional tests, but drives from a variety of manufacturers that feature Super Talent, Samsung, MTRON, and MEMORIGHT.
We were very excited when our friends at DV Nation contacted us about the recent arrival of the latest generation SSD products from MTRON and MEMORIGHT that feature sustained read rates starting at 80MB/sec and going up to 112MB/sec. While these read speeds are impressive, write speed is the one area that SSD drives have generally been weak. The latest controller technology is solving this weakness. As an example, sustained write speeds are up to 105MB/sec in our sample drive from MEMORIGHT . These specifications far exceed those of the latest SanDisk and Samsung consumer SSD products that average 67MB/sec read speeds and 45MB/sec write speeds.
Another area of interest is the capability of the PATA based SSD drives to compete with their SATA cousins. In fact, the overall application results of the PATA based drives are equal to and sometime exceed the SATA drives, although their theoretical results show significantly lower scores at times. We are still researching this phenomenon as it occurs on chipsets from Intel, JMicron, Marvell, AMD, and NVIDIA. We hope to have answers before we lose our hair or the roundup, whichever comes first. It appears at this time that both Dave and I will be bald first.
We received numerous requests for write results on the MTRON drives, so we are providing those results today along with initial results from the MEMORIGHT SATA and MTRON PATA drives. We will be back before CES coverage starts with our first SSD roundup that features six different drives along with some interesting RAID results from our 64GB SSD units. Our numbers today were generated with our new test bed that features an ASUS P5N-T Deluxe motherboard based on the NVIDIA 780i chipset, Intel Q6600 Quad Core processor, and 4GB of OCZ PC2-6400 Flex memory. Our change back to an NVIDIA platform is due to the Intel ICH8/ICH9 chipsets capping SSD performance to 80MB/sec rates, something our NVIDIA or AMD chipsets do not suffer from at this time.
HD Tach 3.01
MTRON 32GB MSP 7000

MTRON 32GB MSD PATA-3025

Memoright 32GB MR25.1-032S

Western Digital Raptor 74GB 0ADFD

Our HD Tach test results heavily favor the MTRON 32GB SATA unit in sustained read rates. The MTRON's average read rate of 112.3MB/sec is about 33% better than the WD Raptor drive at 75.5MB/sec. The biggest difference is the MTRON drive holds the 112MB/sec transfer rate across the entire drive while the Raptor progressively decreases to around 52MB/sec at the end of the drive. The previous MTRON STR results were 95.1MB/sec, which is about 17% slower than the new drive.
The most interesting aspect is the average 83.2MB/sec write speed of the MTRON 32GB SATA drive, just 7% slower overall than the Raptor. However, the minimum write speed of the MTRON SATA unit is around 68MB/sec compared to 20MB/sec on the Raptor. Both of these pale in comparison to the MEMORIGHT 32GB drive that features a sustained write speed of 104.9MB/sec, the fastest we have tested to date. The MTRON 32GB PATA drive features very competitive read rates at 103.4MB/sec but HD Tach reports average write speeds at 39.4MB/sec. However, write speed performance in application testing shows it to be extremely close to the MTRON SATA drives. We will have an update in our roundup, but for now, the PATA drive looks to be a winner for those needing to upgrade an older notebook or extreme benchmarkers needing the fastest IDE drive around.
The burst rates of the Raptor at 130.7MB/sec are slightly higher than the 96~118MB/sec rates on the SSD drives, but burst rates are not nearly as large of a factor as other indicators. Access times greatly favors the SSD drives at .1ms compared to 8.3ms on the Raptor drive. That about does it for today, we will be back shortly with a full performance review on these very fast, but also expensive drives.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3291 (Wayback Machine).