Archive 1997–2024

The Google Mini - A look at Google's entry-level search appliance

Conclusion

After working with the Google Mini for a while in our own lab, it's easy to understand the appeal of a functional, well-tuned search appliance. Correctly configured, the Mini can dramatically enhance users' ability to find both web content, and files and their contents, on the network, and is likely to quickly repay the initial investment with increased productivity.

In terms of price, Google positions the Mini competitively, especially considering the amount of time it would take a company to implement their own fully functional search engine and maintain it. The Mini's array of standard features and flexibility make it too important not to consider.

However, we feel that even though its features are very rich and full of possibilities, the Mini is definitely not the "plug-and-play" machine Google advertises. Though the initial setup might be quick, there is a great deal of difference between the default "search bot" behavior and the fully integrated/optimized searching experience that the Mini is capable of, and we felt that threshold was still just a tad too high. We also noted the rather odd feature restrictions of the Mini as compared to the Google Search Appliance. The restrictions on the maximum number of pages to index is perfectly understandable, but the reasoning that smaller companies would have less use for advanced security systems doesn't make as much sense. A small company looking for an easy and cheap way out might end up surprised by the complexity involved in mastering the behavior of search engines.

To be fair, there simply is no true solution to the search-optimization problem yet. Optimizing searches to best match user behavior has always been a matter of close-up analysis, and the steps Google is taking to facilitate this process are still quite remarkable. As much as we would have loved to have a little peek at what was really going on inside that little blue box, we were satisfied to get a closer look at Google's efforts to put its technology to work in businesses all over the world, and the way they look to increase their users' satisfaction by consistency and simplicity. Though there is definitely room for improvement on the administrative side, the Mini definitely provides its end users the power and familiar feel of the Google web search.

In closing, we'd like to thank Peter Griffin of Google, who helped us out a great deal while exploring the Mini's features.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2407 (Wayback Machine).