Archive 1997–2024

Swiftech H2O-120 Compact and Corsair Nautilus 500: Is Water Better?

Swiftech H2O-120 Compact Specifications

Our test system is Intel Socket 775, but the H2O-120 Compact will also mount on socket AM2 as well as socket 754/939/940 and socket F. All accessories for mounting are included, but mounting on AMD/AM2 sockets requires adapting the Apogee drive block by replacing the bottom half of the Apogee with an AMD specific mounting block. The CPU cage is then removed from the motherboard for the two or four screw direct mount of the drive block


Apogee Drive Block Specifications
Motor Electronically commutated, brushless 12V DC, spherical motor
Nominal Current 0.69A
Weight 286g (10.1 ounces)
Material Diamond Pin Matrix copper base plate
Fittings 3/8" barbs fittings for input and output
Normal Discharge 300 LPH
Nominal Head 10 ft
MTBF 50,000 hours

The included fan is specified at a high 81.3 CFM at 12V, but it is rated at a bit higher noise than we normally see at this output. The 12V rated noise is 36 dB(A). Lowering the fan voltage to 7V with the included electrical adapter drops the noise to 26 dB(A) with the trade-off of much lower airflow. Sleeve bearings are not noted for a long service life, but Swiftech does not specify an average MTBF for this fan.

120mm Fan Specifications
Model RDM1225S
Fan Size 120mm x 120mm x 25mm
Fan Type Low Noise Sleeve Bearing
Maximum Fan Speed 2000 RPM
Maximum Noise Level 36 dB(A) @ 12V, 26 dB(A) @ 7V
Maximum Airflow 81.3 CFM
Current 0.23A
Static Pressure 27mm H2O

The Reservoir/Heat Exchanger utilizes louvered copper fins for best performance. Swiftech claims the system is optimized for high performance at low fan speed where low noise is required.

Radiator/Reservoir Specification
Model MCR120-Res Heat Exchanger
Description 120mm Class Radiator with built-in reservoir. Designed for sealed system with 5 years between refilling
Dimensions 7in x 5in x 1-3/8in (2" thick including barbs)
Material Louvered copper fins, brass tubes & body
Design Optimized for high performance at low fan speed for low noise operations
Fittings Built-in 3/8 in barbs

The Apogee Drive Block is extremely small compared to the size and weight of most of today's better air coolers. This makes the Apogee drive block an easy fit on virtually any motherboard. The only potential issue is the side-mounted 3/8" barbs on the combo block. On some motherboards with tall heatsinks for the power MOSFETs the barbs are potentially not tall enough to clear the tall MOSFET sinks However, we did not encounter this issue with any of the boards we looked at for potential mounting problems.

There are no mounting issues with the EVGA 680i board. Installation was also an easy task on the ASUS Striker and ASUS Commando, and on the two new P35 boards - the ASUS P5K Deluxe and P5K3 Deluxe. The P5K3 Deluxe will likely become a fit test for any motherboard, since the heatpipes completely circle the CPU socket and connect various cooling heatsinks around the CPU socket.


Corsair Nautilus 500 Specifications

The Nautilus 500 was tested on Intel Socket 775. The kit also includes retention brackets for Intel socket 478 and AMD 754/939/940/AM2 sockets. The vinyl tubing for the circulating water is attached to the water block at the factory. The water block remains the same in all possible installations and only the retention mechanism for mounting varies among the different installations. This is an important consideration since this approach ensures that the critical internal water connection is assembled at the factory and already tested for leaks.

Water Pump
Motor Electronically commutated, brushless 12V DC, spherical Motor
Voltage Range 8V to 13.2V
Max Static Pressure 22 PSI
Normal Discharge 350 LPH (@12V)
Nominal Head 13.05 ft

The supporting components and self-contained design makes some small differences in the pump specifications between the Corsair and Swiftech designs. Corsair has also selected a different fan to be integrated in the external cooler. The 1800 RPM Nautilus 500 fan has a maximum air flow of 74.4 CFM, which is slightly less than the 81.3 CFM of the Swiftech. However, static pressure is higher on the Corsair fan.

120mm Fan Specifications
Fan Size 120mm x 120mm x 25mm
Maximum Fan Speed 1800 RPM
Maximum Airflow 74.4 CFM
Current 0.3A
Static Pressure 32mm H2O

CPU Block
Description 100% solid copper supporting Delphi Micro-Channel Technology
Material Solid Copper
Fittings Built-in 3/8 in barbs

The CPU clock looks very similar to the water block used in the Swiftech H2O-120 Compact. The Corsair design uses a stand-alone water block and does not integrate the block and pump as we saw in the Swiftech. This moves the pump noise from inside the case, as in the Swiftech, to outside the case in the cooling box on the Corsair. Which is the better design is a matter for debate, but as you'll see shortly we consider both designs noisier than the best air cooler designs.

There was no problem with fitting the Nautilus 500 waterblock to any motherboard we tested, and in fact we doubt you can find a motherboard that cannot mount the Corsair water block. Since the water block is standalone in the Corsair design there is no potential issue with side barbs as we saw on the Swiftech

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2328 (Wayback Machine).