Archive 1997–2024

Killing the Business Desktop PC Softly

Making sense of CCI

CCI and blade PCs claim to offer three big advantages:
  1. Less power consumption, especially in the office space
  2. Data is centralized and better protected
  3. Less administration costs, less downtime
Less power consumption is very unlikely as:
  • The current business desktops use and can use much more efficient CPUs and PSUs. Low voltage desktop CPUs are available, consuming less than 35W
  • Many business desktops are replaced by laptops which consume less than 40W in total
  • In the CCI model, you have two devices instead of one, which makes it much harder to consume less than one PC
Centralizing data doesn't require CCI. It is enough to use roaming profiles that are only allowed to write on network drives. So the big gains must come from the third point: less administration, less downtime. Indeed, since the thin client doesn't have any moving parts, it breaks down less often. By using a rather basic operating system instead of a bloated one, it requires a lot less attention. With all of the software is running on the blade, it is somewhat easier to manage.

The biggest window of opportunity for CCI is in enterprises with a lot of geographically dispersed sales offices like a bank. You don't want to have a system administrator traveling around to visit all those sales offices, and you don't want to see your sales people stand by doing nothing while their PCs are getting repaired or reconfigured. You just keep one or two (or more) thin clients in reserve, and if one breaks down, you immediately replace it with a new one. But even then, CCI might be between a rock and a hard place as there are a lot of competing technologies which try to lower the TCO of the desktop PCs.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2279 (Wayback Machine).