Archive 1997–2024

Coming Soon to HD DVD: Silicon Optix HD HQV

HD HQV Performance

For these tests, we will be using a beta version of PowerDVD HD 6.5 along with hardware acceleration to play back the HD HQV HD DVD. This works much the same as it did with the standard definition HQV test which is a collection of clips playback from a DVD. The software DVD, HD DVD or Blu-ray player, with hardware acceleration enabled, will use the graphics hardware to offload the decode process from the CPU. The byproduct of this is that image quality is more influenced by the hardware being used than the software when using hardware acceleration.

For AMD we are using Catalyst 7.1, and for NVIDIA we look at 93.71 for the 7 series and 97.92 for the 8 series. Our results on both 7 and 8 series cards for NVIDIA are the same, so there will be no distinction between the two when talking about NVIDIA results. This comparison is as much between AVIVO and PowerDVD HD as it is of the hardware at this point. Both AMD and NVIDIA should have some headroom for improving performance through their drivers in the future.

The maximum score for HD HQV is 105 with 80 of those points having to do with proper deinterlacing of interlaced HD sources. All broadcast HD sources in the US today are interlaced, and there are many HD DVD movies provided in 1080i as well. Fewer Blu-ray titles are 1080i, but they aren't impossible to find. While our HD DVD version of HQV obviously tests HD DVD players, these features will be important for the playback of any interlaced HD source. Because of this, we really expected NVIDIA and AMD to perform well.

Unfortunately, reality did not live up to our expectations. We'll break it down by test. While we would love to provide screenshots, our version of PowerDVD doesn't support screenshots, and taking pictures of the TV just doesn't provide the detail we need. Descriptions of what's going on will have to do for now.

Noise Reduction

Both AMD and NVIDIA score a flat zero on this test. None of the AMD or NVIDIA cards we tested performed any noise reduction on either the flowers or the boat scene. There weren't any artifacts present, but it is very clear that neither camp performs any noise reduction on HD video at this point.

Video Resolution Loss

AMD averages fields and thus looses detail. The result is a gray color filling the corner blocks rather than alternating fine lines. NVIDIA doubles the scanlines in one field and eliminates half of the data, as the corner blocks are solid colors. This means that both solutions fail in different ways. PowerDVD's software performs similarly to AMD hardware, which means that currently available computer hardware and software will not faithfully reproduce interlaced video.

Jaggies

Once again, AMD and NVIDIA both fail to eliminate diagonal aliasing. This is another example of the poor deinterlacing provided by computer hardware and current drivers. Eliminating jaggies is a major way to improve the visual experience of watching interlaced video on a progressive display like a 720p or 1080p HDTV or a computer monitor.

Film Resolution Loss

Like the video resolution loss test, both NVIDIA and AMD fail this test. The failure was a result of the same problems we saw in the video resolution loss test, meaning that rather than performing inverse telecine, both AMD and NVIDIA treat 1080i created from a film source the same way they would treat video. For AMD this means averaging fields, and for NVIDIA this means eliminating half the fields.

Film Resolution Loss - Stadium Test

When playing on AMD hardware, flickering is apparent in the stadium. While NVIDIA hardware doesn't flicker, a moiré pattern is apparent in the stands. Both of these fail to pass the test and demonstrate different issues that can appear when film is poorly deinterlaced.

The overall result?

AMD: 0
NVIDIA: 0


Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2168 (Wayback Machine).