Coming Soon to HD DVD: Silicon Optix HD HQV
- Posted in
- GPUs
Final Words
This is one of those times summing up is easy: both AMD and NVIDIA fail utterly at every test HD HQV throws at them. Advanced deinterlacing algorithms used on standard definition video are just not present when working with HD video. We are lacking inverse telecine and noise reduction as well. Watching interlaced HD content on a progressive scan monitor using a computer is not going to deliver an optimal experience until AMD and NVIDIA get with the program and start extending their image quality improving algorithms to HD interlaced content.
While watching 1080p content using a modern graphics card will not have many of the issues illuminated by HD HQV, noise reduction would definitely help. With higher resolution content, issues like noise are actually more noticeable and distracting. Ideally, movie studios would perform noise reduction on their content before encoding it for distribution, but this just doesn't happen right now.
With cable and satellite carrying interlaced video, watching TV and recorded content on the computer will be the more important benefactor of high quality deinterlacing support on graphics hardware. Of course, owners of 1080i HD DVDs and Blu-ray movies won't want to be overlooked. It could be argued that good deinterlacing is more important on cable boxes or TVs, but stand alone HD DVD and Blu-ray players are out there that provide higher quality deinterlacing and noise reduction than can currently be achieved on a PC. In fact, Silicon Optix not only makes the HD HQV benchmark, but their HQV line of video processors featured in high end consumer electronics devices is designed to pass all of the tests featured in their benchmark.
We certainly hope AMD and NVIDIA will pay some much needed attention to their HD video processing and address the issues we've seen here. As many of the techniques used in standard definition video processing can be extended to HD processing, we hope that future driver updates will make things more interesting. If and when we see something more interesting happen on PC graphics hardware, we will revisit the issue. We also plan on comparing the PC and consumer electronics hardware in the future as well.
This is one of those times summing up is easy: both AMD and NVIDIA fail utterly at every test HD HQV throws at them. Advanced deinterlacing algorithms used on standard definition video are just not present when working with HD video. We are lacking inverse telecine and noise reduction as well. Watching interlaced HD content on a progressive scan monitor using a computer is not going to deliver an optimal experience until AMD and NVIDIA get with the program and start extending their image quality improving algorithms to HD interlaced content.
While watching 1080p content using a modern graphics card will not have many of the issues illuminated by HD HQV, noise reduction would definitely help. With higher resolution content, issues like noise are actually more noticeable and distracting. Ideally, movie studios would perform noise reduction on their content before encoding it for distribution, but this just doesn't happen right now.
With cable and satellite carrying interlaced video, watching TV and recorded content on the computer will be the more important benefactor of high quality deinterlacing support on graphics hardware. Of course, owners of 1080i HD DVDs and Blu-ray movies won't want to be overlooked. It could be argued that good deinterlacing is more important on cable boxes or TVs, but stand alone HD DVD and Blu-ray players are out there that provide higher quality deinterlacing and noise reduction than can currently be achieved on a PC. In fact, Silicon Optix not only makes the HD HQV benchmark, but their HQV line of video processors featured in high end consumer electronics devices is designed to pass all of the tests featured in their benchmark.
We certainly hope AMD and NVIDIA will pay some much needed attention to their HD video processing and address the issues we've seen here. As many of the techniques used in standard definition video processing can be extended to HD processing, we hope that future driver updates will make things more interesting. If and when we see something more interesting happen on PC graphics hardware, we will revisit the issue. We also plan on comparing the PC and consumer electronics hardware in the future as well.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2168 (Wayback Machine).