Archive 1997–2024

ATI's Avivo vs. NVIDIA's PureVideo: De-Interlacing Quality Compared

De-Interlacing Quality - Mixed 3:2 Film with Added Video Titles
"Filmed content edited electronically for video can introduce additional problems for a video processor. 30 fps video elements, such as title crawls and scene transitions, may confuse the processor as it tries to detect and hold a 3:2 sequence, preserving the smooth motion of 24 fps film.

A worst-case scenario is when a movie is transferred to video for broadcast or distribution on DVD and an entirely new electronic end title sequence is created. The best video processors will be able to distinguish between film and video content, converting different parts of the image of a per-pixel basis.

Look closely at the various filmed scenes to see if image detail is preserved while electronic titles crawl across and up the screen. Are diagonal lines smooth, or jagged? Is the title crawl text smooth and crisp, or does it appear soft and degraded?"
While NVIDIA does well in this first test, there are noticeable interlacing artifacts in the ATI screengrab:



Hold mouse over image to see NVIDIA's Image Quality.

The same applies to the second test:



Hold mouse over image to see NVIDIA's Image Quality.

In the third and final horizontal scrolling test, both ATI and NVIDIA suffer from poor de-interlacing (note the artifacts in the guitar strings), thus bringing both down to a score of 5. Although, it's clear that NVIDIA did better than ATI when looking at all three tests as a whole.



Hold mouse over image to see NVIDIA's Image Quality.


Scoring Description (Horizontal Text Crawl)
10 THE TEXT IS CRISP, THE CRAWL IS SMOOTH, AND THE BACKGROUND IMAGE EXHIBITS EXCELLENT DETAIL WITHOUT SCAN LINE ARTIFACTS ("JAGGIES")
5 THE CRAWLING TEXT IS SMOOTH AND CRISP, BUT THE BACKGROUND IMAGES HAVE NOTICEABLE SCAN LINE ARTIFACTS
0 THE CRAWLING TEXT EXHIBITS NOTICEABLE TEARING OR COMBING

Much like the earlier horizontal scroll tests, while NVIDIA produced a fairly clean image, you can see some artifacts in the ATI shot:



Hold mouse over image to see NVIDIA's Image Quality.


Scoring Description (Vertical Text Scroll)
10 THE CREDIT SEQUENCE TEXT MOVES SMOOTHLY UP THE SCREEN, THE TEXT IS SHARP AND CRISP, AND THE BACKGROUND IMAGE EXHIBITS EXCELLENT DETAIL WITHOUT SCAN LINE ARTIFACTS ("JAGGIES")
5 THE SCROLLING TEXT IS SMOOTH AND CRISP, BUT THE BACKGROUND IMAGES HAVE NOTICEABLE SCAN LINE ARTIFACTS
0 THE SCROLLING TEXT EXHIBITS NOTICEABLE TEARING OR COMBING


Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1809 (Wayback Machine).