Archive 1997–2024

ATI's Avivo vs. NVIDIA's PureVideo: De-Interlacing Quality Compared

Final Words

We excluded a few of the tests from our image quality comparisons, simply because they were more focused on noise reduction and both ATI and NVIDIA did equally poorly there. Instead, we decided to focus on cadence detection and de-interlacing quality, using the tests from the previous pages.

Let's first look at how all of the numbers tally up for ATI and NVIDIA:

Test NVIDIA PureVideo ATI Avivo
Color Bar/Vertical Detail 5 5
Jaggies Pattern 1 3 3
Jaggies Pattern 2 3 0
Flag 5 5
Picture Detail 0 0
Noise Reduction 0 0
Motion Adaptive Noise Reduction 0 0
3:2 Detection 10 10
Film Cadence
2:2 0 0
2:2:2:4 0 0
2:3:3:25 5 0
5:5 0 0
6:4 0 0
8:7 0 0
3:2 5 5
Scrolling Text (Horiz) 5 5
Scrolling Text (Vert) 10 5
Total 51 38

The subjective numbers add up to pretty much summarize our experience with ATI's Avivo at this point. While neither ATI nor NVIDIA produced a perfect solution, at this point, Avivo is definitely a step behind NVIDIA's PureVideo in terms of de-interlacing quality.

We will be keeping tabs on ATI's Avivo as its remaining, and arguably more exciting, features get implemented in later driver revisions. For now, be sure to read our technology and gaming performance coverage on ATI's Radeon X1000 line.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1809 (Wayback Machine).