Archive 1997–2024

Asustor AS6204T Braswell NAS Review

Multi-Client NFS Performance for Professional Workloads

We looked at the multi-client performance of CIFS shares for professional workloads in the previous section. In a similar manner, we also evaluated the multi-client NFS performance of the Asustor AS6204T. Instead of the Windows 7 VMs, we used CentOS 7 VMs. The network configuration remained the same. The NFS share exported on the NAS was mounted with the following options.

<NAS_IP>:/PATH_TO_NFS_SHARE /PATH_TO_LOCAL_MOUNT_FOLDER nfs rw,relatime,vers=3,rsize=32768,wsize=32768,namlen=255,hard,proto=tcp,timeo=600,retrans=2, sec=sys,mountaddr <NAS_IP>,mountvers=3,mountproto=udp,local_lock=none,addr=<NAS_IP> 0 0

Using a popular filer benchmarking program, we did played back the same multi-client real-world professional workload access traces used in the previous section. Similar to the strategy for the CIFS performance evaluation, failing to meet the required op rate criteria at a particular load point made us stop the testing a couple of load points down the road. NFS shares on the Asustor AS6204T with four 7200 RPM hard drives in RAID-5 can support, at any given point of time, recording of 10 or more video streams, or, up to 4 software builds, or, up to 3 virtual desktops. However, it can't support any database operations.

Database Operations

The Database Operations workload was a challenge to get up and running on a NFS share in the AS6204T. This workload makes extensive use of server-side NFS locking. Asustor's currently available firmware doesn't support NFS server locks (lockd). Upon providing an error report, they got back to me with a beta firmware integrating NFS server lock support. It enabled the workload trace to replay properly, but, unfortunately, the op rate seems to be limited by the software rather than the disk IOPS. The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here

Database Operations - Op Rates

Database Operations - Bandwidth and Latencies

Software Builds

The Software Builds workload seems to get acceptable performance for up to four clients.The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here

Software Builds - Op Rates

Software Builds - Bandwidth and Latencies

Video Recording

The Video Recording workload seems to get acceptable performance for more than 10 clients.The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here

Video Recording - Op Rates

Video Recording - Bandwidth and Latencies

Virtual Desktops

The Virtual Desktops workload seems to get acceptable performance for up to three clients.The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here

Virtual Desktops - Op Rates

Virtual Desktops - Bandwidth and Latencies

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/9753/asustor-as6204t-braswell-nas-review (Wayback Machine).