Archive 1997–2024

ARM Challenging Intel in the Server Market: An Overview

Overview of the Competitors

Let's sum everything up in one big table.

ARM/Intel SoC 2015 Comparison
SoC Intel Xeon-D Intel Atom C2000 AppliedMicro X-Gene 1
(X-Gene 2)
AMD A1100 Cavium Thunder-X Broadcom Vulcan
Architecture Broadwell Silvermont Storm (ShadowCat) A57 Thunder-X Vulcan
Cores
Socket
8
single
8
single
8 (16)
sngle
4-8
single
16-48
dual
20?
Max. CPU Clockspeed GHz 2.4GHz 2.4GHz
(2.8GHz)
2GHz 2.5 Ghz 3GHz
Process technology Intel 14nm Intel 22nm TSMC 40nm
(TSMC 28nm)
GF 28nm GF 28nm TSMC 16nm
L1 Cache 32KB I
32KB D
32KB I
24KB D
32KB I (*)
32KB D (*)
48KB I
32KB D
78KB I
32KB D
32KB I
32KB D
Decode 4 2 4 3 2 4
Max. IPC (int) 5 2 4 3 2 4
Exe Ports 8 4 8 8 4? 6
Max. FP Performance 2x 256 bit 1x 128 bit 2x 128 bit 2x 128 bit 2x 128 bit 2x 128 bit
OoO buffer 192 32 >100 128 40 180
L2 Cache 8x 256KB 4x 1MB 4x 256KB? (*) 4x 1MB 16MB 20x 256KB
L3 Cache 8MB? - 8MB 8MB - ?
Max. RAM 128GB 64GB 128GB 128GB 1TB ?
Memory Bus Width 2x 64-bit 2 x 64-bit 4x 64-bit 2x 64-bit 4x 64-bit 4x 64-bit
DRAM (best) DDR4-
2133
DDR3-
1600
DDR3-
1866
DDR3-
1866
DDR4-
2133
DDR4-
2133
TDP (top SKU) 45W 20W 40W
(25 W?)
25W +/- 95 W ?
Available Q2-Q3
2015
Early
2014
Now
(Q2 2015?)
Q1-Q2
2015
Q1
2015
Q3
2015

(*) Deduced from Ganesh's article about the Helix SoCs

These are paper specifications of course, so they should be interpreted with a grain of salt. It looks like the AMD A1100 should top the Atom C2000 and go after the low end of the Xeon E3. AMD's Opteron A1100 is already available, but the current development kits do not hit the clock speed and performance targets.

The Thunder-X single-threaded performance in "traditional workloads" might only be at the level of the Atom C2000, but scale-out and network/crypto acceleration could give some remarkable results in certain workloads. The Cavium SoC is the hardest to predict and will show a very variable performance profile as it also incorporates many very specialized hardware accelerators. The Thunder-X reference servers are announced and should be available in the coming weeks.

The X-Gene is currently the widest ARM architecture with extra hardware acceleration mostly focused on networking. The X-Gene TDP was great on paper (25W when announced) but there are many indications (40W TDP) that AppliedMicro really needs the 28nm X-Gene 2 to be truly competitive in the performance/watt battle arena. The X-Gene 2 should be available around Q2 2015.

 

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/8776/arm-challinging-intel-in-the-server-market-an-overview (Wayback Machine).