Archive 1997–2024

LRDIMMs, RDIMMs, and Supermicro's Latest Twin

Value for Money: the Supermicro Server

It is pretty hard to compare the Supemicro Twin with other servers on the market. Firstly, HP and Dell do not fully disclose the pricing of their dense rack servers. Secondly, as each server vendor has its own chassis and form factors, it is very hard to find a close match.

By puzzling together the available information from the HP (US) and several Supermicro (US based) resellers, we were able to make a rather rough comparison. Take it with a grain of salt as both servers are not completely targeted at the same market, but they are similar and the targeted markets do overlap.

DIMM price comparison
Description System Remark Price
Chassis S6500 Empty Chassis $2549 : 2 = $1274 *
Node 1 HP ProLiant SL250s Gen8 2U 2 x Xeon 2665, 8GB $5659
Node 2 HP ProLiant SL250s Gen8 2U 2 x Xeon 2665, 8GB $5659
Total Base System     $13593
       
Supermicro 6027TR-D71RF      
Chassis 6027TR-D71RF+ Chassis with motherboards $2500
Extra 4 x Xeon 2665, 2 x 8GB To compare with HP $6000
Total Base System     $8500

*Chassis is 4U, with four 2U servers

HP designed a 4U server in which you can fit four half width 2U rack servers. We divided the chassis cost by two, to get an idea of how two HP SL-servers compare with the Supermicro 2U Twin.

As always, such a proprietary "blade-ish" design comes with a premium. The result is that the HP server is about 50% more expensive. The next thing you have to do is fill the server with DIMMs.

DIMM price comparison
DIMM Type Speed Vendor Price
8GB RDIMM 1600MHz HP 647899-B21 $191
8GB RDIMM LV 1333MHz—LV HP 647897-B21 $146
16GB RDIMM 1600MHz HP 672631-B21 $ 405
16GB RDIMM LV 1333MHz—LV HP 647901-B21 $386
32GB LRDIMM LV 1333MHz—LV HP 647885-B21 $2000
       
8GB RDIMM 1600MHz Samsung $150
16GB RDIMM 1600MHz Samsung $290
16GB LRDIMM 1333MHz Samsung $460
32GB RDIMM 1333MHz Samsung $1560
32GB LRDIMM 1333MHz LV Samsung $1150

HP's pricing is pretty decent until we go up in DIMM capacity. The 8GB premium is around $40 per DIMM, which is relatively small in a $10000 server. At most you will paying about $640 extra if you buy 16 DIMMs. Once you get 16GB DIMMs, you are paying $115 more per DIMM, or a price premium of 40%. At $400 per DIMM, the DIMM investment starts to eat up a large share of the server budget.

Although the comparison is far from perfect, the conclusion is pretty straightforward. If hardware costs play an important role in your IT budget, Supermicro offers much more for your dollar. Two fully populated (16x16GB) Supermicro Twin servers will cost about $26k; a quad 4U HP S6500 server will run about $40k.

Of course, If the deal is part of a larger IT project involving consultancy and software costs, HP can make a case. Nevertheless, it must be said that the pricing of the Supermicro's servers is very attractive.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/6068/lrdimms-rdimms-supermicros-latest-twin (Wayback Machine).