LaCie's 2big NAS Review
- Posted in
- IT Computing
- Storage
- NAS
- LaCie
A CentOS 6.2 virtual machine was used to evaluate NFS and CIFS performance of the 2big NAS when accessed from a Linux client. In order to standardize the testing across multiple NAS units, the following parameters were used to mount the NFS and Samba shares:
mount -t nfs NAS_IP:/PATH_TO_NFS_SHARE /PATH_TO_LOCAL_MOUNT_FOLDER -o async,hard,proto=tcp,noac
mount -t cifs //NAS_IP/PATH_TO_SMB_SHARE /PATH_TO_LOCAL_MOUNT_FOLDER -o directio
Note that we have not tried to optimize NFS performance for the NAS. In order to keep things as uniform as possible, we will just look at comparative performance on the basis of the default mounting options
combined with the above (which are set to avoid caching effects on the client side).
In the previous section, the tests conducted on the LaCie 2big NAS were repeated on the Synology DS211+ (using the same hard drives). In this section, we benchmarked both the NAS units using IOMeter using the scripts available here. The tables below presents the various results.
NFS Performance
| NFS Throughput (Av. MBps) | ||||
| Test Name | LaCie 2big NAS | Synology DS211+ | ||
| Read | Write | Read | Write | |
| Max Throughput 100% Reads | 44.48 | - | 38.89 | - |
| Real Life - 60% Random - 65% Reads | 0.78 | 0.41 | 0.8 | 0.43 |
| Max Throughput - 50% Reads | 11.3 | 11.27 | 16.31 | 16.30 |
| Random 8KB - 70% Reads | 0.72 | 0.31 | 0.79 | 0.34 |
| NFS Access IOPS | ||||
| Test Name | LaCie 2big NAS | Synology DS211+ | ||
| Read | Write | Read | Write | |
| Max Throughput 100% Reads | 1423 | - | 1245 | - |
| Real Life - 60% Random - 65% Reads | 100 | 53 | 102 | 55 |
| Max Throughput - 50% Reads | 362 | 361 | 522 | 522 |
| Random 8KB - 70% Reads | 92 | 40 | 101 | 43 |
| Average Response Time (ms) | ||||
| Test Name | LaCie 2big NAS | Synology DS211+ | ||
| Read | Write | Read | Write | |
| Max Throughput 100% Reads | 41.16 | - | 47.3 | - |
| Real Life - 60% Random - 65% Reads | 395.48 | 388.92 | 383.6 | 375.02 |
| Max Throughput - 50% Reads | 81.64 | 82.64 | 56.48 | 56.90 |
| Random 8KB - 70% Reads | 454.64 | 450.96 | 416.95 | 406.1 |
CIFS Performance
| CIFS Throughput (Av. MBps) | ||||
| Test Name | LaCie 2big NAS | Synology DS211+ | ||
| Read | Write | Read | Write | |
| Max Throughput 100% Reads | 30.11 | - | 28.75 | - |
| Real Life - 60% Random - 65% Reads | 0.71 | 0.38 | 0.94 | 0.51 |
| Max Throughput - 50% Reads | 14.43 | 14.38 | 13.93 | 13.78 |
| Random 8KB - 70% Reads | 0.58 | 0.25 | 0.80 | 0.34 |
| CIFS Access IOPS | ||||
| Test Name | LaCie 2big NAS | Synology DS211+ | ||
| Read | Write | Read | Write | |
| Max Throughput 100% Reads | 964 | - | 920 | - |
| Real Life - 60% Random - 65% Reads | 90 | 49 | 121 | 66 |
| Max Throughput - 50% Reads | 462 | 460 | 446 | 441 |
| Random 8KB - 70% Reads | 74 | 32 | 103 | 43 |
| Average Response Time (ms) | ||||
| Test Name | LaCie 2big NAS | Synology DS211+ | ||
| Read | Write | Read | Write | |
| Max Throughput 100% Reads | 61.64 | - | 64.5 | - |
| Real Life - 60% Random - 65% Reads | 428.19 | 433.97 | 323.14 | 318.6 |
| Max Throughput - 50% Reads | 64.22 | 64.31 | 66.82 | 67.02 |
| Random 8KB - 70% Reads | 563.62 | 570.60 | 415.35 | 408.04 |
A look at the tables above indicate that the 2big NAS wins on some benchmarks, while the Synology DS211+ wins on others. It appears that they are pretty evenly matched when it comes to performance in a Linux environment, though the NFS implementation in NAS OS 2 could do with some improvements.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/5838/lacies-2big-nas-review (Wayback Machine).