AMD and Intel Mobile Rematch: Gateway NV5933u vs. Acer 5542
Battery Life Compared
The last time we looked at battery life, Intel's Core 2 platform had a clear lead over AMD. Both platforms have gotten faster, but what about battery life? As we showed last year with the Gateway NV52 and NV58, the choice of OS makes a difference. Again, we are using the Windows 7 results from the NV52/NV58 to keep things equal, which means battery life improved quite a bit over the Vista results.




And here's where things get interesting. Performance improved on both platforms, but our initial battery life testing shows that battery life actually got worse on both AMD and Intel. The closest result is for AMD on the Internet test, where the old and new platforms essentially tie. x264 battery life dropped 8% on both platforms as well. The big drops come in idle battery life and Internet on Intel. Both drop 18-19% in idle battery life, while the NV59 takes a relatively drastic hit of 25% in our Internet test. Not shown in the charts is Blu-ray battery life on the NV59, which we clocked at just 98 minutes. The extra power required to spin the optical drive plus the decoding of a 37Mbit AVC movie takes its toll on every laptop we've tested so far. We need much more than a 48Wh battery to get through most Blu-ray discs.
That said, we need to take these results with a grain of salt. The old Core 2 platform was very mature at the time of our previous testing, and we've seen other laptops offering impressive battery life using i-Series processors. The ASUS U30Jc is a smaller 13.3" LCD, but even taking that into account it was able to deliver 5.67 minutes per Wh of battery capacity, which is 50% higher than the 3.75 result of the NV59. Both the M300 and M600 laptops we tested continue to have a poor showing in battery life overall, with the higher clocked M600 generally trailing the M300. Both are rated as 35W TDP, but all 35W processors are not created equal.
The real question is how optimized the notebooks are in terms of power saving features. We saw a BIOS/VBIOS update on MSI's GX640 improve battery life by up to 50%. It's doubtful that we'd get that much of an improvement on IGP-based laptop designs, but ASUS' Power4Gear utility has proven useful in boosting battery life in our testing by allowing you to disable the optical drive and webcam when you're on battery power. We'd like to see more manufacturers include such utilities, as well as simply putting more effort into creating a power efficient platform. Whether it's lack of power optimizations, immature platforms, old battery technology, or some other factor, the fact remains that both of the newcomers offer disappointing battery life.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3773/amd-and-intel-mobile-rematch-gateway-nv5933u-vs-acer-5542 (Wayback Machine).