Archive 1997–2024

The Highest-End Notebooks, 2009

System Performance

We'll begin with a look at general system performance using PCMark and applications that can take advantage of the multi-core processors.

Futuremark PCMark05

Futuremark PCMark Vantage 64-bit

Video Encoding - DivX

Video Encoding - x264

Video Encoding - x264

3D Rendering - CINEBENCH R10

3D Rendering - CINEBENCH R10

The three desktop replacement notebooks place at the top of our performance charts in PCMark, video encoding, and 3D rendering benchmarks. Not surprisingly, the desktop i7-975 offers far more performance in video encoding and 3D rendering tests. The i7-920XM also outperforms the Core 2 QX9300 in CPU intensive tasks despite its lower clock speed, albeit by a small margin, so given the choice Core i7 is better than Core 2 Quad. However, let's talk about PCMark for a minute.

The Eurocom M980NU looks very slow compared to the two other notebooks in PCMark. The reason is really quite simple: it doesn't have an SSD. Eurocom initially shipped us a system with an SSD, but we had some problems (apparently a flaky GPU) and the second system included a conventional hard drive. While there's no denying that SSDs are faster than hard drives, at least if you get a good SSD that doesn't degrade performance over time, PCMark places an unusually high weight on hard drive transfer rates -- which means things like the RAID 0 SSDs in the D900F really skew the results. Here are the detailed results for the notebooks.

PCMark05 Breakdown
  AVADirect D900F Clevo W870CU Eurocom M980NU 1GPU Eurocom M980NU SLI
PCMark05 Score 14730 11053 8382 8953
HDD XP Startup (MB/s) 67.38 22.57 8.36 8.53
Physics and 3D (FPS) 328.1 247.2 242.6 240.0
2D Transparency (Win/s) 8082 7975 4711 6538
3D Pixel Shaders (FPS) 820.3 792.6 825.7 773.0
Web Rendering (Pages/s) 4.900 2.914 2.619 2.762
File Decryption (MB/s) 91.60 75.25 68.44 68.05
2D 64 Line Redraw (FPS) 2394 1734 1258 2365
HDD General Usage (MB/s) 38.09 35.58 6.05 6.49
Multitasking 1 1000 739 630 627
Audio Compression (KB/s) 4745 3451 3287 3276
Video Encoding (KB/s) 792.2 594.6 449.5 445.9
Multitasking 2 1000 698 734 750
Text Editing (Pages/s) 213.2 139.1 144.9 152.5
Image Decompression (MP/s) 45.93 34.18 36.21 36.01
Multitasking 3 1000 879 754 755
File Compression (MB/s) 14.91 9.02 10.62 10.62
File Encryption (MB/s) 88.03 56.28 66.57 66.73
HDD Virus Scan (MB/s) 113.4 153.6 97.6 97.6
Memory Latency (MAcc/s) 13.88 12.70 9.55 9.55

PCMark Vantage Breakdown
  AVADirect D900F Clevo W870CU Eurocom
M980NU 1GPU
Eurocom
M980NU SLI
PCMark Vantage 12128 9637 5245 5599
Memory 6429 6693 4050 4249
TV and Movies 5527 4426 3668 3918
Gaming 15570 12264 4870 4925
Music 10494 8486 3954 4160
Communications 8917 6369 5072 5215
Productivity 15368 10663 5222 5358
HDD Test 18361 15111 3490 3956

Not surprisingly, the D900F is the fastest option almost across the board. The only areas where it loses are PCMark05's HDD Virus Scan and PCMark Vantage's Memory tests. It also ties one of the other notebooks in a few tests (within 3%). The M980NU on the other hand should have done a lot better in the graphics tests, but the only area where it matches the D900F is in 2D 64 Line Redraw. While 3DMark is really good at punishing your GPU, PCMark doesn't appear to place nearly as much weight on graphics performance. Even better is the "Gaming" test suite in PCMark Vantage, which is clearly more of a hard drive benchmark -- unless you actually think the D900F is more than three times as fast as the M980NU SLI setup?

Put another way, don't place too much stock on PCMark's overall score. It's just a number, and these systems are all more than fast enough to handle just about any task you might want to do. Gaming and graphics are clearly the forte of the M980NU, and SSDs won't actually make your system three or four times as fast -- although you might be able to launch five applications at once and have them load 10 times as fast. Let's move on to our other tests.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2858/the-highest-end-notebooks-2009 (Wayback Machine).