The Highest-End Notebooks, 2009
Conclusion
Our opinions haven't changed much from the Clarksfield launch, but this time we have more to say about the notebook specifics. We'll start with the Clevo W870CU.
Clarksfield looks to be a reasonable processor, despite relatively high prices. Users should be able to get better than Core 2 Duo performance for single-core and dual-core tasks, along with better than Core 2 Quad performance on multithreaded tasks. This is all thanks to the Turbo modes on Clarksfield, and it's nice that Intel allows the mobile variants to boost a lot higher relative to the desktop Lynnfield parts. As much as we like Clarksfield, we really aren't very happy with the Clevo W870CU design. The construction of the chassis just feels cheap in a few places, and that's not something you want from a notebook that will cost well over $2000. The little hatch covering the rear ports is also a very poor design, as it only serves to get in the way. Finally, the W870CU really needs a larger battery in order to make it attractive relative to other options. Really, if you're looking for a high-performance desktop replacement, we feel you would be better served by one of the other two notebooks and you should give the W870CU a pass. Once we see SLI variants of Clarksfield, our opinion might change, but right now a slightly lower price and slightly lighter chassis isn't enough to convince us the W870CU is a good notebook.
The AVADirect/Clevo D900F is an easier recommendation. It's big, heavy, and it runs pretty hot, but it also has the fastest consumer CPU currently available. If you don't care about graphics performance, you could pick up the D900F in place of a desktop workstation and the only thing you would give up is expansion options -- and more money. You can configure the D900F with 6GB or 12GB RAM, and you have eight virtual CPU cores available if you run virtualized operating systems. If you're on the road a lot and you need a good mobile workstation, the D900F is worth a serious look. For gamers, once again we would give this one a pass; gaming GPUs are nowhere near as fast as desktop GPUs, so you would be better off getting the fastest graphics setup you can afford if you're looking for a mobile gaming solution. Or, you could learn to get by with something a lot less powerful and turn down the details in your games, saving a couple thousand dollars in the process.
The Eurocom M980NU represents the current fastest gaming solution, at least if you're looking at NVIDIA GPUs. Alienware's M17x is similar, and Alienware even supports ATI HD 4870 CrossFire, but with the mobile driver situation we would recommend sticking with NVIDIA's mobile GPUs -- especially if you plan on running multiple GPUs. That makes the GTX 280M SLI our preferred high-end gaming solution for notebooks, and you have a choice between notebooks like the Eurocom M980NU and Alienware M17x. The M980NU offers a larger LCD, which means it also weighs a bit more, but we're happy to report that it's a good quality 1080p LCD. Pricing also favors Eurocom (and other vendors that carry similar designs) over the Alienware M17x. The catch is that the Alienware M17x supports hybrid GPUs, allowing you to switch between discrete and integrated graphics. It requires a reboot, but it's nice to be able to get over two hours of battery life on your $3000+ notebook when you want it. The M980NU does support more hard drives, so you can get the benefits of RAID 0 SSDs as well as cheap mass storage. Our biggest complaint with the M980NU is the mirror finish on the cover and palm rest; look at the Dell Precision M6400 to see the sort of styling we'd prefer on a large notebook. Ultimately, you really need to like mobile gaming if you're looking at these sort of notebooks, because a $3000 desktop could easily run circles around the M980NU. (Core i7-860 overclocked to 4.2GHz, dual HD 5870 GPUs, and 4x2GB DDR3-1600 RAM with a 30" LCD would cost less money than this particular M980NU.)
The short summary then is that the AVADirect D900F is the fastest mobile processing platform we've ever seen -- and the fastest we're likely to see for a while. The Eurocom M980NU goes the other route and provides the fastest overall gaming laptop we've tested to date. It's not likely to have as much staying power, as NVIDIA will likely have faster mobile GPUs sometime in the next year, and there are definitely situations where the GTX 280M GPUs are CPU limited. It will be interesting to see how dual-GPU notebooks based on Clarksfield perform; if you're not in a rush, it might be worth waiting for someone to come out with an i7-920XM SLI gaming notebook, but if the past is any Indication it could be six months before such a product is available for purchase.
For the rest of us that don't have $3000 burning a hole in our wallets, the more interesting option is going to be Arrandale. We should start seeing the initial Arrandale laptops in early 2010, at which point we will hopefully get better CPU performance, better battery life, and better graphics.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2858/the-highest-end-notebooks-2009 (Wayback Machine).