Upgrading and Analyzing Apple's Nehalem Mac Pro
- Posted in
- Mac
No 2.5” Drive Bays?
I expect innovation from Apple. The first to use SSDs on their shipping notebooks, the first to use DisplayPort yet Apple was beat to the punch by HP in bringing 2.5” drive bays to market in a desktop?
The overwhelming majority of SSDs these days are made for notebooks and thus they come in 2.5” form factors. The added space of a 3.5” chassis isn’t very useful with SSDs since the limiting factor for how much flash you can put on a drive is cost, not space.
The numbers I presented in The SSD Anthology apply to Macs as well; the fresh start test depicted in the graph below is just as applicable under OS X as it is under Vista:

While Apple won’t ship any of Intel’s X25-Ms in its machines today (for reasons that I unfortunately can’t talk about but have nothing to do with technology), there’s nothing stopping its end users from making the upgrade.
The problem is that the Mac Pro doesn’t really accommodate such an upgrade very well. There aren’t any cheap 2.5” to 3.5” adapters that will work with the Mac Pro’s drive sleds so you’re left having to construct such a thing on your own. The SATA and power interfaces are standard, so the drives will work just fine, you just need a way of securing them in the chassis.

A hanging SSD in the Mac Pro. Won't Apple please provide a 2.5" drive option?
I’d expect that Apple would be the one to do this but I guess taking care of its customers spending over $3000 on a machine isn’t really at the top of anyone’s list over there. Even the MacBook and MacBook Pro get SSD options; it’s not the fastest SSD in the world but the option is there.
Apple could have easily added a single 2.5” drive bay somewhere in the case for a SSD application/boot drive, or offer an optional 2.5” sled to replace one of the four 3.5” sleds in the system. It’s a simple change that wouldn’t take an engineer long to design; Apple could call it the iForgot.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2800/upgrading-and-analyzing-apple-s-nehalem-mac-pro (Wayback Machine).