Archive 1997–2024

Understanding the iPhone 3GS

A Testament to Honesty about Battery Life

I follow AMD's Patrick Moorhead on Twitter and recently he's been on a tirade against MobileMark 2007 and those who use it to characterize notebook battery life. Moorehead's complaint is motivated by the fact that Intel performs better on MobileMark than AMD (possibly due to better power characteristics at idle conditions), but it highlights another truth: most notebook makers can't be trusted when it comes to battery life claims.

In my recent MacBook Pro coverage I pointed out that this wasn't true for Apple. Apple claimed that the new MacBook Pro could last up to 7 hours on a single charge under a wireless productivity test, and my own tests backed up that assertion. Apple said its new 15-inch MacBook Pro could last up to 7 hours and my tests showed between 5 - 8 hours of battery life depending on workload.

Apple isn't very specific with the MacBook Pro battery life, you just get an upper limit. With the iPhone however, Apple has gotten much better at indicating battery life. In nearly every single test I ran, Apple's advertised battery life and the battery life I actually experienced were almost identical.

Apple claims that web browsing on WiFi should last you about 9 hours on the new iPhone 3GS; mine lasted 8.83 hours. Apple said on 3G I should get 5 hours, I got 4.81. For video playback Apple said the new iPhone 3GS should deliver 10 hours of battery life, I estimated around 9 (I was at the 5 hour mark with more than 50% of my battery left). Apple also does a bang up job on detailing its testing methodology if you care to read how Apple tests.

While I'll always run my own tests to verify Apple's claims, I will say that I've never been this impressed by a manufacturer's honesty with regards to performance claims. Apple gets praised for its design, attacked for its secrecy but it should be commended for its transparency and honesty when it comes to battery life specs on its products.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2798 (Wayback Machine).