Archive 1997–2024

The Core 2 Quad Q8400: Intel's $183 Phenom II 940 Competitor

Overclocking with a 10% Increase in Core Voltage

While there's something nice about not having to do anything to overclock your CPU other than adjusting a single parameter, tweaking your core voltage has the potential to significantly increase your overclocking potential.

Let's start with the Phenom II X4 940. Using the stock AMD cooler and pushing a max 10% increase in core voltage we ended up with 3.6GHz and a 2.2GHz NB frequency at 1.475V:

I was able to get the chip up to 3.9GHz but not stable enough to complete all of my tests over a significant period of time. Still, a 20% overclock with a moderate increase in core voltage isn't bad at all.

The Core 2 Quad Q8400 saw a 15% increase in clock speed without touching the core voltage. Bumping the core voltage up to 1.45V bought us another 11% taking the chip up to 3.36GHz:

At 3.6GHz vs. 3.36GHz, AMD's clock speed advantage grows to ~7%. Not as big as the 12.7% clock speed advantage at stock frequencies but bigger than the 4% difference in our stock voltage OC attempt.

Processor Adobe Photoshop CS4 x264 HD - 2nd pass POV-Ray Far Cry 2 Idle Power Load Power
AMD Phenom II X4 940 @ 3.6GHz 20.3s 21.3 fps 2839 51.5 fps 120.8W 256W
Intel Core 2 Quad Q8400 @ 3.36GHz 18.0s 22.3 fps 2771 59.5 fps 139.9W 213W

 

At max overclock something interesting happens. Obviously the Q8400 holds on to the lead in Photoshop and Far Cry 2, but POV-Ray goes back to AMD. The x264 encode ends up being a mild victory by the Q8400. Far Cry 2 is bizzare as the Phenom II saw no performance improvement from 3.2GHz up to 3.6GHz, regardless of how many times I ran the test I could never get a higher frame rate out of the system - even with CnQ disabled.There must be some other bottleneck operating here, but it's not a GPU one since the Q8400 was able to scale all the way up to 59.5 fps with the same graphics card.

The situation seems to boil down to this - at max frequency the Phenom II will probably retain its performance lead in 3D rendering and ray-tracing applications, while the video encoding lead goes to Intel. Power consumption also favors the Q8400 significantly.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2762 (Wayback Machine).