Archive 1997–2024

The Core 2 Quad Q8400: Intel's $183 Phenom II 940 Competitor

Overclocking at Stock Voltages

The Phenom II X4 940 was AMD's first Phenom II to hit the market, the downside being that it wasn't the best example of AMD's 45nm manufacturing process. While the chips could overclock, their headroom without increasing their default core voltage just wasn't that high. The 940 we used for this review could only make it to 3.2GHz with a 2.2GHz NB frequency without increasing core voltage beyond the default 1.35V (as reported by the BIOS, 1.336V as reported by CPU-Z):


Phenom II X4 940 max overclock at stock voltage

The Core 2 Quad Q8400 on the other hand is based on a core that's been shipping for quite a while, at stock voltage using the stock cooler I was able to hit 3.08GHz:

Now remember that Phenom II isn't faster than Intel's Core 2 Quad clock for clock. AMD gets an advantage only because it sells higher clocked Phenom IIs at the same price as lower clocked Core 2 Quads. With only a 4% clock speed advantage, the performance is distinctly in Intel's favor:

Processor Adobe Photoshop CS4 x264 HD - 2nd pass POV-Ray Far Cry 2 Idle Power Load Power
AMD Phenom II X4 940 @ 3.2GHz 22.3s 19.0 fps 2539 51.5 fps 120.2W 209W
Intel Core 2 Quad Q8400 @ 3.08GHz 19.7s 20.4 fps 2597 53.5 fps 131.9W 181.5W

 

Photoshop and Far Cry 2 were both Q8400's strengths at stock clock speeds, so it makes sense that the Q8400 would widen the gap after we overclocked both chips. The x264 and POV-Ray tests were equal and in AMD's favor, respectively, at stock clocks. When overclocked without touching anything but the clock multiplier in the case of the Phenom II or FSB frequency and memory ratios in the case of the Core 2 Quad.

There is merit to looking at this sort of overclocking performance since it's the simplest way to overclock, but if you're willing to give your chip a little more voltage you can get a lot more clock speed...

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2762 (Wayback Machine).