CES 2009 - TV Trends, WirelessHD, 240Hz and Netbook Pricing
- Posted in
- Trade Shows
Ridiculous Netbook Pricing
Thanks for listening to me talk about TVs for a while, now let’s move on to more PC-topics. In particular, I’d like to address the ridiculous nature of netbook pricing.
I had the pleasure of dining with Intel’s Mooly Eden at CES. You may remember Mooly as the father of Centrino; he headed up the Banias design team, which was responsible for the very first Centrino CPU. These days Mooly is more marketing than engineering, but he hasn’t lost his ability to be frank.
I talked to Mooly about how the Atom processor wasn’t delivering enough performance for the netbooks that it’s in. I asked him what happens once Moorestown comes around; will Atom continue to be the netbook CPU of choice or will Intel introduce a very scaled down Nehalem for netbooks and use Atom in smartphones and other smaller devices?
To my surprise, Mooly said that the Atom delivered fine performance for netbooks. But it turned out that Mooly and I had very differing views on netbooks. Mooly’s view was that netbooks should be ultra affordable devices priced between $299 and $349. At those prices, Atom does deliver enough performance.
The reality of the situation however, is that manufacturers are shipping netbooks in the $500 - $900 range (way to go Sony) and outfitting them with 1.6GHz and even 1.33GHz Atom processors. I get that you’re paying a premium for the size of the device, but it seems to me that manufacturers are capitalizing on the newness of netbooks by attempting to price them much higher than they should be.

Stylish, it'll fit in your purse, but it's still got a CPU slower than what was in a mainstream notebook from 2004.
While Dell and HP should be commended on entering the market at or near that $299 - $349 range, I’d like to see more of that sort of behavior from their peers in the market. I think it’s very telling that Apple has opted out of building an Atom-based system thus far; the only reason it makes sense is if you price it very low, and that’s not something Apple would do. The alternative would be putting an Atom in a higher priced notebook, which would compromise the experience, something Apple is also not too keen on doing.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2706 (Wayback Machine).