Archive 1997–2024

The Cost of Running Your PC

The Difference a Few Percent Makes

Hopefully we've made it clear that upgrading an existing power supply to a higher efficiency model purely for the power savings doesn't make sense. However, there are times when you need to buy a new power supply, so we will wrap things up with a closer examination of how efficiency impacts power costs. Should you really care about the difference between 85%, 87%, or 90% efficiency?

This time, we don't need to worry about specific systems, but instead we will focus on efficiency and monetary savings at various power loads. The following table is again a best-case scenario for saving money -- i.e. you are running the system 24/7. Efficiency 1 is the base value and we compare the savings you would gain by selecting a power supply that achieves Efficiency 2. Efficiency ratings at the various loads represent what you might realistically find in various high-end power supplies currently on the market -- so getting 90% efficiency with a load of only 50W isn't going to happen.

Savings from Incrementally Higher Efficiency - 24/7 Yearly Usage
Output - Watts Efficiency 1 Efficiency 2 Savings NC Savings CA Savings GER
50 78% 79% $0.53 $0.91 €1.56
($2.03)
80% $1.05 $1.80 €3.09
($4.01)
81% $1.56 $2.66 €4.58
($5.95)
82% $2.05 $3.51 €6.03
($7.83)
200 80% 81% $2.03 $3.46 €5.95
($7.73)
83% $5.94 $10.13 €17.41
($22.64)
85% $9.66 $16.49 €28.34
($36.84)
87% $13.22 $22.55 €38.77
($50.40)
400 85% 86% $3.60 $6.14 €33.61
($43.70)
87% $7.11 $12.13 €10.55
($13.71)
88% $10.54 $17.99 €20.85
($27.10)
89% $13.90 $23.72 €30.92
($40.19)
700 85% 86% $6.29 $10.74 €18.45
($23.99)
87% $12.44 $21.23 €36.49
($47.43)
88% $18.45 $31.48 €54.11
($70.34)
89% $24.32 $41.50 €71.33
($92.73)

Obviously, the higher the load the better your savings, since a difference of 1W hardly matters. Your best course of action would be to select a power supply that offers the best efficiency at the load you will use most frequently. So for example, if you only play games on your computer and otherwise have it shut off, you might seriously consider a power supply with optimal efficiency at the 500W-600W range. On the other hand, if you typically just surf the Internet you'll probably be more interested in the efficiency at 100W-200W.

At the maximum load of 700W, and going with German power costs, the difference between an 85% and 89% efficiency power supply could be as much as €71. That's enough to get a significantly better power supply, but of course that sort of savings is unrealistic since it will be extremely difficult to achieve a 700W load all the time. The 400W load represents a more realistic maximum, as something like an overclocked quad-core system running Folding@Home could actually draw that much power around the clock. In that case, your savings could still be a pretty significant €30 per year, so over three years you could save almost €100. If you only run the system eight hours per day, however, the difference in cost drops off quickly.

Obviously, spending $20 more just to increase efficiency by 1% isn't necessary. You'll probably use a power supply for at least three years, so all other things being equal higher efficiency is good. That "all other things" is the problem, however, since rarely are the other areas the same. Pay attention to the other features like noise levels, voltage regulation, and the number and type of connector as well. Also keep in mind that we still have changing ATX standards, and sometimes new connectors, so spending a small fortune on a top quality PSU that might be outdated in a year or two might not be the best course of action either.

The bottom line ends up being a simple case of common sense: don't buy more power supply than you actually need, and don't spend a lot of money for a small increase in efficiency. Figure out how much power your system will normally use, and then choose a power supply appropriate for that sort of workload. If you routinely stress your system (i.e. workstation loads or intense gaming), an extra $100 for a high-end power supply might be a good idea. For most users, however, moderation will be the better course of action.

Finally, we spent quite a bit of time putting together the spreadsheet that we used to generate the tables in this article. We selected a few different markets for our power costs, and then we selected several different systems. Obviously, we couldn't cover everything, but for those who are interested in running their own calculations we thought you might appreciate our spreadsheet. Feel free to insert your own KWh costs, efficiency, and system power requirements to see how things change. (The highlighted fields should be the only areas you need to modify.)

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2668 (Wayback Machine).