The Cost of Running Your PC
- Posted in
- Cases/Cooling/PSUs
Using a Higher Efficiency PSU to Reduce Costs
These days manufacturers are all promoting their high efficiency power supplies, and we have organizations and certifications like 80 Plus encouraging even small boosts in efficiency. Not surprisingly, plenty of users have been sucked in by the marketing and are now convinced that they need to purchase a new power supply in order to save money each year. Does it really make that much of a difference? The answer as usual depends on how you use your system. The previous page provided a baseline measurement, but now let's look at how much money you can save if you go out and purchase a new 80 Plus Bronze or Silver certified power supply as an upgrade to a slightly older ~80% efficiency PSU.
Our sample power supplies on the previous page are all relatively high-end choices for the specific market. Many (most) systems don't have power supplies anywhere near that nice, relatively speaking. So what happens when we switch to an older ATX 1.3 PSU -- something that would have been more or less state-of-the-art three years ago? Will a newer power supply really help you save the planet? Will it at least reduce your power costs and save you money? Let's find out, this time looking at power costs over the course of a full year: 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
For reference, we looked at some PSU efficiency results stashed away in our files and estimated ATX1.3 PSU efficiency at 75% idle and 78% load. That represents a high-end ATX1.3 PSU, and in some cases the discussion is hypothetical as it wouldn't be possible to find an older PSU with the necessary output rating. (That applies specifically to the high-end system.)
| System 1 24/7 Yearly Costs ATX1.3 versus ATX2.2 |
||||||
| Outlet Power ATX v2.2 |
Outlet Power ATX v1.3 |
Wattage Difference |
Savings NC | Savings CA | Savings GER | |
| Idle | 110 | 120 | 10 | $6.57 | $11.21 | €19.27 ($25.05) |
| Load | 167 | 179 | 12 | $7.88 | $13.46 | €23.13 ($30.06) |
| System 2 24/7 Yearly Costs ATX1.3 versus ATX2.2 |
||||||
| Outlet Power ATX v2.2 |
Outlet Power ATX v1.3 |
Wattage Difference |
Savings NC | Savings CA | Savings GER | |
| Idle | 190 | 213 | 23 | $15.11 | $25.79 | €44.33 ($57.62) |
| Load | 412 | 449 | 37 | $24.31 | $41.49 | €71.31 ($92.70) |
| System 3 24/7 Yearly Costs ATX1.3 versus ATX2.2 |
||||||
| Outlet Power ATX v2.2 |
Outlet Power ATX v1.3 |
Wattage Difference |
Savings NC | Savings CA | Savings GER | |
| Idle | 369 | 413 | 44 | $28.91 | $49.34 | €84.80 ($110.24) |
| Load | 663 | 705 | 42 | $27.59 | $47.09 | €80.94 ($105.23) |
Now we can see exactly how much money you might save during the course of a year by purchasing a new high efficiency power supply. Obviously, the more power your computer uses, the better your monetary savings. Looking at these tables, you might begin to think there's actually a point in upgrading power supplies -- and there is, provided you're running your computer a large portion of the time.
What happens if we change our usage model to something more realistic for most families? Instead of looking at 24/7 usage, let's change it to three hours of use per day on average, with two hours at idle and one hour at load.
| Yearly Power Savings for 3 Hrs/Day | |||
| Savings NC | Savings CA | Savings GER | |
| System 1 | $0.88 | $1.50 | €2.57 ($3.34) |
| System 2 | $2.27 | $3.88 | €6.66 ($8.66) |
| System 3 | $3.56 | $6.07 | €10.44 ($13.57) |
The need to upgrade power supplies suddenly doesn't seem as dire once we switch to a more realistic usage model. Particularly on low-end systems that only use 100W of power give or take, even an extremely inefficient PSU probably doesn't matter too much if the system isn't on more than a few hours per day. Even with power costs that are up to three times higher in some parts of Europe compared to areas in the US, the savings don't make sense.
If you happen to be the type of user that leaves your system on all the time, certainly you can save a fair amount of money by purchasing a better power supply. An easier solution would simply be to turn off your computer when it's not in use, unless you have a really good reason to leave it running overnight. Similarly, if your current PSU happens to fail, it might be worthwhile to spend a little bit more money to get a higher efficiency, better quality power supply. If you figure on a moderate amount of use and a five-year lifespan, you might want to spend as much as $50-$100 extra. Otherwise, there's very little incentive to go out and spend $150 on a top quality power supply just so you can save $10-$15 per year (or less).
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2668 (Wayback Machine).