Archive 1997–2024

Mobile Roundup: A Trio of Midrange Laptops

High Detail Gaming and 3DMark

We also ran a few games at higher detail settings to really drive the point home. Even at 1280x800, these mobile GPUs struggle in many modern titles, and cranking up the details levels is not at all recommended.







Futuremark 3DMark03

Futuremark 3DMark05

Futuremark 3DMark06

Futuremark 3DMark Vantage

There's nothing really new here, other than frame rates becoming even lower. The results in 3DMark don't necessarily mean a lot in terms of real gaming performance, but it is somewhat interesting that the M-152XL is faster in 3DMark03 and slower in 05/Vantage. 3DMark06 seems to correlate the best with our gaming results, where in the majority of games the ATI and NVIDIA options are essentially tied. The Acer and AVADirect of course offer the same performance, since the two GPUs are simply different names for the same chip. There are a few minor variations caused by drivers, but otherwise everything is well within the margin of error.

Something not shown in the gaming charts is that performance even at low or medium detail settings often remains unacceptable at 1280x800. As an example, Mass Effect at minimum detail settings (which still looks decent) struggled to get above 20 FPS. Race Driver: GRID fares a little better, reaching around 25 FPS, but the loss in visual detail is far more noticeable than in Mass Effect. Crysis is another title that really isn't intended for GPUs of this level, regardless of settings. In short, you'll want to limit yourself to older games or low to medium detail levels (at best) with midrange mobile GPUs. To summarize the gaming equation, we hope the following table makes things clear:

1280x800 Performance vs. GeForce 9800M GTS (Gateway P-7811)
  Acer 6920G AVADirect
FL-92
Gateway
M-152XL
Gateway
P-7811 FX
Assassin's Creed DX9 50.04% 50.80% 53.58% 100%
Assassin's Creed DX10 44.97% 43.60% 52.16% 100%
Company of Heroes DX9 31.45% 30.62% 33.67% 100%
Company of Heroes DX10 32.27% 30.91% 30.00% 100%
Crysis - Medium 50.26% 44.40% 55.78% 100%
Crysis - High 42.91% 39.71% 48.02% 100%
Devil May Cry 4 32.78% 31.59% 23.83% 100%
ET Quake Wars 0xAA 39.02% 40.17% 39.96% 100%
ET Quake Wars 4xAA 30.67% 31.96% 26.55% 100%
Race Driver: GRID 0xAA 34.80% 37.14% 39.06% 100%
Mass Effect 41.83% 37.38% 48.05% 100%
Oblivion 35.31% 33.64% 38.58% 100%
Unreal Tournament 3 38.77% 38.30% 42.20% 100%
Average All Games 38.85% 37.71% 40.88% 100%
         
9800M GTS Advantage 254.1% 261.6% 240.2% 100.0%

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2621 (Wayback Machine).