Archive 1997–2024

Mobile Roundup: A Trio of Midrange Laptops

Standard Gaming Performance

Unlike the gaming notebooks we recently reviewed, performance in games definitely isn't the most important criterion in determining which of these laptops is best. If you care about gaming, you basically have two options. First, you can get a decent desktop that will easily outperform pretty much any laptop at a fraction of the price; the second option is to spend more money and buy a gaming notebook. Of course with the Gateway P-7811 you won't have to spend more than about $1400, but in terms of gaming performance the GeForce 9800M GTS is going to be slower than the desktop 9600 GT (a sub-$100 part these days).


















There are differences between the three midrange laptops in some of the titles, but most of these differences are pretty insignificant compared to the large elephant standing over in the corner. That large elephant is represented by the P-7811, which provides over twice the performance of the other GPUs in virtually every game. We have to question the need for these "midrange" mobile GPUs, as it seems most users that want better than integrated graphics are going to want a lot more (i.e. 9800M), or else they just need the video decoding capabilities provided by entry-level options like the GeForce 9300M. Give us a 9800M or HD 3870 with the option to disable it and run off an IGP, and we'd be a lot happier than these relatively slow GPUs. The ATI HD 3200 IGP is another great option for non-gaming laptops, although that would mean would need an AMD laptop instead of Core 2 Duo. However, as a complete package, an AMD CPU and IGP will often be a better choice than an Intel CPU and IGP.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2621 (Wayback Machine).