Archive 1997–2024

Transcend 16GB SSD

Conclusion

Transcend's TS16GSSD25-S is a very solid offering for its intended market, coming in at performance and price levels similar to what we'd expect from the mainstream generation of SSD cards. While the MTRON drive soundly trounces the Transcend in all tests, there's no comparison between the two devices in the marketplace - the MTRON commands a price of over $1000, which is roughly three times more expensive than either the Transcend or the Super Talent.

As we can see from the overall benchmark scores, the appeal of SSD as a replacement for conventional hard drives is still a mixed bag depending upon your application. The SSD devices in this particular market sector simply cannot produce the throughput of a modern conventional hard drive, and this keeps it marginalized in most situations. Access times are much better, but overall performance typically favors conventional drives.

The capacity of the unit further limits its appeal - where a large capacity SSD device would seem to be a natural choice for most HTPC or desktop replacement situations based on the strength of its silent and cool operation, 16GB is far too small for any serious home theater user or for most SOHO type designs where a premium is placed on digital content. 32GB (which is the largest SSD in the Transcend product line) may be enough for limited use in these situations; however, we need to keep in mind this product was designed for a different purpose.

Desktop performance is not the real purpose of the Transcend SSD - or notebook performance for the most part, unless the performance happens to involve battery life, temperatures, durability, and/or noise levels. We can't accurately determine how well the current SSDs will hold up over the next few years, but at the very least a drive head crash or bearing failure is no longer going to be a concern. With claims of 10 year MTBF rates, the Transcend drive certainly looks to be more reliable. What we'd really like to see is a warranty to back that up - and considering the price and reliability claims, some provision for data recovery on any failed drives would go a long way toward making the drive more attractive. As it stands, we have lofty claims accompanied by a short two year warranty, and for the price you could purchase several identical conventional drives and set up a backup routine that would provide better long-term data retention.

The Transcend SSD card offers decent write performance, though its read speed trails the Super Talent SSD in all tests. With this in mind, and given the comparable street prices of the two devices, the ideal choice for some users may not be the Transcend TS16GSSD25-S but instead the Super Talent drive, though both serve their purpose well depending upon the configuration utilized. Given Transcend's history and traditional position as one of the leaders in the flash memory business, however, we look forward to Transcend's next generation offerings to see how those devices fare. With further price drops and improved capacities, it seems likely that SSDs will eventually reach the point where they can begin to overtake most conventional drives.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2358 (Wayback Machine).