AMD's Opteron hits 3.2GHz
- Posted in
- IT Computing
Conclusion
The best news for AMD is that the newly launched 8224SE and 8222 will outperform the current Xeon MP by a significant margin. However, AMD will have very little time to enjoy that victory as the new Xeon MP based on the Core architecture is going to launch very soon. That leads us to the dual socket space. Here's a recap of the various benchmarks that we have run.
Intel has a clear lead in the rendering market. If you are rendering complex high resolutions images, the quad core Xeon is clearly the best choice. If you are rendering normal resolution pictures, quad core might not really pay off, but the dual core Xeon will still be a bit faster than the Opteron. Both Cinebench and 3ds max have been "mildly" optimized for SSE2, but if you use a carefully SSE2 optimized application the Opteron's lack of SSE power is painfully obvious: the Intel CPUs are up to 70% faster in SSE-heavy code. That is one specific area that Barcelona should remedy in the coming months. If you are in for a new server for your FP intensive applications, it might be interesting to wait a bit and see how Harpertown compares to Barcelona; if you can't wait, right now Intel is the first choice in this market.
When it comes to the purely business processing, such as database processing and java applications, we feel that the answer cannot be given so quickly. If your application is usually under high load, the Intel CPUs are clearly better. They use slightly less power than the Opteron SE and run faster. Especially if your application is based on databases such as DB2, Oracle, and MS SQL server, it is clear that the quad core Xeon still rules. The quad core Xeon may not be a "native quad core" design, but it was surely a brilliant move by Intel. Until AMD's own quad core comes out, this market will be out of reach of AMD.
However, some servers are only stressed during a short period of time or are based on mediocre scaling software like MySQL. In that case, the Opteron 2222 makes a lot of sense. The cores will run at a low and cool 1GHz most of the time and consume very little power. Our Tyan Server saved no less than 184W during the "calm periods" and that is a lot of power. That amount of power has to be multiplied by +/- 1.5 (adding your air conditioning's energy consumption) to calculate the total energy consumption savings, making power savings even more significant. During periods of high load, the Opteron 2222 still offers decent performance at a slightly lower price than the dual core 3.0GHz Xeons.
The most interesting thing about AMD's latest launch is probably that AMD has now a 3GHz Opteron that consumes very little when running at low load while it keeps the power consumption reasonable at full load. The Opteron 2224 SE will only interest the people who have already invested in clusters of cheap socket F servers and who are looking to squeeze more performance out of them. If you haven't made that investment already, there's nothing really new or surprising with the latest launch, so you might be best off waiting a bit longer to see what the future holds.
The best news for AMD is that the newly launched 8224SE and 8222 will outperform the current Xeon MP by a significant margin. However, AMD will have very little time to enjoy that victory as the new Xeon MP based on the Core architecture is going to launch very soon. That leads us to the dual socket space. Here's a recap of the various benchmarks that we have run.
| Performance Comparison | |||
| General applications | Opteron 3.2GHz vs. DC Xeon 3GHz | Opteron 3GHz vs. DC Xeon 3GHz | Opteron 3GHz vs. QC Xeon 2.33GHz |
| General applications | |||
| WinRAR 3.62 | 8% | 5% | -17% |
| 3D Applications | |||
| 3DS Max 9 | -11% | -16% | -34% |
| Cinebench 9 | 0% | -7% | -14% |
| zVisuel 3D Kribi Engine | -31% | -32% | -40% |
| Server applications | |||
| SPECjbb | 0% | -4% | -30% |
| MySQL | -12% | N/A | N/A |
Intel has a clear lead in the rendering market. If you are rendering complex high resolutions images, the quad core Xeon is clearly the best choice. If you are rendering normal resolution pictures, quad core might not really pay off, but the dual core Xeon will still be a bit faster than the Opteron. Both Cinebench and 3ds max have been "mildly" optimized for SSE2, but if you use a carefully SSE2 optimized application the Opteron's lack of SSE power is painfully obvious: the Intel CPUs are up to 70% faster in SSE-heavy code. That is one specific area that Barcelona should remedy in the coming months. If you are in for a new server for your FP intensive applications, it might be interesting to wait a bit and see how Harpertown compares to Barcelona; if you can't wait, right now Intel is the first choice in this market.
When it comes to the purely business processing, such as database processing and java applications, we feel that the answer cannot be given so quickly. If your application is usually under high load, the Intel CPUs are clearly better. They use slightly less power than the Opteron SE and run faster. Especially if your application is based on databases such as DB2, Oracle, and MS SQL server, it is clear that the quad core Xeon still rules. The quad core Xeon may not be a "native quad core" design, but it was surely a brilliant move by Intel. Until AMD's own quad core comes out, this market will be out of reach of AMD.
However, some servers are only stressed during a short period of time or are based on mediocre scaling software like MySQL. In that case, the Opteron 2222 makes a lot of sense. The cores will run at a low and cool 1GHz most of the time and consume very little power. Our Tyan Server saved no less than 184W during the "calm periods" and that is a lot of power. That amount of power has to be multiplied by +/- 1.5 (adding your air conditioning's energy consumption) to calculate the total energy consumption savings, making power savings even more significant. During periods of high load, the Opteron 2222 still offers decent performance at a slightly lower price than the dual core 3.0GHz Xeons.
The most interesting thing about AMD's latest launch is probably that AMD has now a 3GHz Opteron that consumes very little when running at low load while it keeps the power consumption reasonable at full load. The Opteron 2224 SE will only interest the people who have already invested in clusters of cheap socket F servers and who are looking to squeeze more performance out of them. If you haven't made that investment already, there's nothing really new or surprising with the latest launch, so you might be best off waiting a bit longer to see what the future holds.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2294 (Wayback Machine).