Archive 1997–2024

AMD's Opteron hits 3.2GHz

Power

Our AMD system had a different but similar power supply as our Intel system. The fan setup was also different, but the peak power consumption of the fans of both systems was very close. If you would like a completely apples-to-apples comparison (or at least as close as we can get), we'll refer to our previous performance/watt measurements which have been done with almost identical systems. Take these Intel versus AMD figures with a grain of salt, but the comparison between the different AMD CPUs is still very interesting.

Power Usage
  SPECjbb Cinebench (Load) Idle PowerNow! Idle Load vs. Idle Savings Idle PowerNow/EIST Savings
Dual Xeon 5160 3.0 376 354 248 244 110 4
Dual Xeon E5345 2.33 374 331 248 244 87 4
Dual Opteron 2224 SE 380 409 310 159 250 151
Dual Opteron 2222 330 342 259 158 184 101
Dual Opteron 8218HE 2.6 GHz 279 299 225 155 144 70

To be fair, we are using somewhat early Intel samples; the current Intel CPUs will probably consume a little less power due to process maturity and other minor tweaks. Still, it is very clear that AMD's CPUs are able to save a lot more when they are not stressed. What kind of power savings may you expect when you buy a lower power Opteron?

Power Savings
  SPECjbb Cinebench Idle PowerNow! Idle
Normal 95W vs. SE 119W 50 67 51 1
HE 68W vs. Normal 95 51 43 34 3

The above table makes a few interesting points
  • It is quite impressive that the AMD Opteron 2222 is now able to reach 3GHz at 95W. This means that, compared to just 2-3 months ago, you save up to 67W per server and get the same performance (2222 versus the older 2222SE).
  • AMD's PowerNow! Technology is very efficient: it saves you between 150W and 250W depending on system load and configuration. 250W seems impossible, but the three fans of our Tyan TA26 had to run at much higher speeds to cool the CPUs at 3.2GHz than at 1GHz.
  • The gains of Intel's EIST are very limited: the CPUs only throttle back to 2GHz.
The fact that the Opterons consume less power when running SPECjbb2005 versus running Cinebench 9.5 is quite interesting, as the Intel systems actually consume a bit more. Since SPECJbb2005 is a rather memory intensive benchmark, the reason for this difference is quickly found: the extra power consumption of the FB-DIMMs negates the fact that SPECjbb2005 is less CPU intensive than Cinebench. Or if you look at it another way: Intel's system consumes a bit less when running Cinebench as the FB-DIMMs have very little to do. Combined with the latency penalty we have measured, we wouldn't be surprised if Intel relegates FB-DIMMs to a small high-end niche market in the future.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2294 (Wayback Machine).