Archive 1997–2024

Killing the Business Desktop PC Softly

Blade PCs

Next up is the blade PC. The challenge is to make sure that the blade PC and the thin client consume less energy together than a typical business desktop. The big advantage of a blade PC is that all PCs draw from the same the power supply, which allows for the use of a more efficient power supply. HP has designed an enclosure that can house up to twenty blade PCs in a single 3U rack mount chassis, all of which are powered by the same redundant 600W power supply. That means that each blade PC consumes less than 30W.

The HP BladeSystem bc2000 and bc2500 consist of:
  • Low voltage AMD Athlon 64 X2 Dual-Core 3000+ processor (1.60 GHz 2x512K L2) (bc2500) or AMD Athlon 64 2100+ (1.2 GHz 512K L2) (bc2000)
  • ATI RS690T/SB600 w/integrated DirectX 9 compliant graphics
  • Up to 2x2GB 667 MHz DDR2 SDRAM
  • 2.5" 80GB 5400 rpm SATA 1.5 Gb/s
  • 100 Mbit Ethernet (Broadcom 5906M)
When looking at the CPU and HP's PSU specs, something isn't right. The AMD Athlon 64 2100+ is indeed a very low voltage version of the single core Athlon 64 and probably consumes something like 10-15W. However, the Athlon 64 X2 LV at 1.6 GHz is speced as a 35W CPU. Yes, the CPU will probably never need more than 30W, but still a 600W PSU is never going to be able to cope with 20 blades, when the CPU alone is capable of consuming 30W. Each blade can be equipped with 2 DIMMs and a mobile SATA hard disk, which is easily another 15W. Still, most press releases and documents talk about a 600W PSU. Delving a bit deeper, we found a PDF with a short chapter that describes a 1000W PSU.

If you only need a 1.2 GHz Athlon 64, it becomes less clear why you would allocate a blade PC for each user. You might be better off with VDI for example (see below). It might seem like nitpicking, but if you want to add a full rack of relatively modern PCs with dual core CPUs, the system administrator of the data center has to cope with another 12-14 KW (bc2500). If you chose the bc2000 blade, you are looking at only 7.6KW per rack. Clearly there is nothing magical about blade PCs: a 50W blade PC and 15W-30W thin client are not going to save much power compared to a desktop with the same (low voltage) dual core CPU.

Let's take a closer look at the blade PC.


The HP blade PC bc2000

It is a pretty elegant and slim design with a small heatsink on top of the CPU, and two SO-DIMMs for memory expansion. If you don't like your blade PC to be headless, you can add an old Lynx EM4+ video chip which supports an 800x600 resolution when you access the blade PC directly.


Adding a video chip to the blade PC

The video chip plugs into the black "IDE-like" connectors. The second generation of blade PCs still has room for improvement: why use a hard disk if your data is going to be saved on centralized network storage? Solid state drives were probably too expensive at the time of the new blade PC design, but basically the design right now has room for improvement.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2279 (Wayback Machine).