Archive 1997–2024

Killing the Business Desktop PC Softly

Conclusion

In many scenarios is the Blade PC a rather complex way of solving the TCO problem of the traditional desktop PC. It seems to be a case of throwing out the child with the bath water. There is a lot that can be done to lower the TCO of the PC:
  • Use energy efficient components; PCs that use one or more mobile components are already available
  • Avoid using moving parts, such as CPU fans or hard disks; this will soon be possible, as Solid State devices get cheaper and low voltage CPUs are available
  • Make the PC a stateless device by using roaming profiles
  • Use (semi) automated management of images (Altiris or similar)
  • Store all data and profile information on network storage
Basically you could call this thin PC a mix of mobile and thin client technology. This seems to beat blade PCs:
  • Downtime is minimized: you can swap one PC for another one
  • Good 3D graphics performance does not require high amount of continuous bandwidth
  • As you have only one computer instead of two (thin client + blade PC), energy bills will be lower
  • TCA is much lower
  • Most of the administration and management costs are reduced, making the difference with a blade PC very small
So it seems that for heavier office and CAD tasks a well managed PC is still the better deal. The relatively high price that HP and others ask for a low end PC in "Small Blade Form Factor" makes it hard to get a good return on investment.

Right now, VDI is not really a competitor, as you can only run a limited number of desktops on one server if you want the same guaranteed performance and RAM space as with blade PCs. As a result the licensing cost of the virtualization software per desktop quickly increases. That is why current implementations of VDI mostly target light loads that are not compatible with SBC. When you run 20 or more desktops from one server, the (e.g. VMWare ESX/infrastructure) licensing costs start to become significant.

CCI and blade PCs do have a window opportunity. As long as VDI licensing cost are relatively high and as long as most business PCs are not (fully) optimized for TCO, blade PCs make a lot of sense in an enterprise with many small remote offices. In that case, if something goes wrong with something like a software deployment, it is good to be able to administer it locally, keeping the infrastructure close to where the system administrators are located.

The business PC is not going away (at least not yet), but as virtualization gets more mature and flexible (and as graphics cards get virtualized too), and as competition heats up, the most promising technology is still VDI. VDI might even prove to be an alternative to blade PCs. For now, SBC and Terminal Services are the only alternatives to desktop PCs that have a proven track record of lowering TCO. At least that is our analysis; what do you think? Let us know!

We'd like to thank Koen Slechten, De Witte Pierre (HP Belgium) and Carine Goris (IBM Belgium) for their help.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2279 (Wayback Machine).