EVGA nForce 650i Ultra: Performance on a Budget
- Posted in
- Motherboards
Final Thoughts
This is our first look at a true NVIDIA budget solution for the Intel platform. NVIDIA has done a terrific job combining the 650i SLI SPP and nf430 MCP into a board design that offers extremely competitive performance at a compelling price point. This is the same design philosophy that NVIDIA is using with the 680i LT SLI chipset but we felt like that EVGA board lacked a finishing coat of polish. In some ways we feel the same way about the EVGA 650i Ultra board as well.
Don't get us wrong: we think the performance of the board and the basic features are terrific for an estimated selling price around $95 to $99, especially when looking at other Intel solutions in this price range. However, we firmly believe that a few additions such as memory voltages to 2.2V, CPU VTT / GTL Ref voltage control, Firewire, and maybe a six-layer board design would have placed this board in the exceptional category for those enthusiasts on a budget.
What those extras would have meant in additional cost is something we will never know, but if it only meant a few extra dollars then we firmly believe they would have been well worth it. As it is, we have to judge the board on its own merits against other offerings in the same price range and with that we present it a Silver Editors' Choice Award.
The EVGA 650i Ultra stands out from other boards in this price category by offering top tier performance in several areas and a feature list that cannot be beat at very reasonable pricing. When comparing features to Intel P965 chipsets found in this price sector we see our EVGA 650i Ultra offering onboard RAID, asynchronous memory capability, and best-in-class overclocking for the same or less money. The addition of GPU optimizations that offer a free 2% to 4% improvement with certain GPUs in our gaming scores is an added bonus.
We did not experience any major problems with the board during an intense week long test schedule utilizing Windows XP. We did find a few minor issues with nTune, a fan header that is thermally preset to 60C before the fan will operate, and a few overclocking nuances with our quad core CPU due to crosstalk problems on the board. We just started Vista testing on this board and will provide an update in our upcoming roundup article. We have not experienced issues in Vista yet other than immature driver release problems. It appears from our forums and others that NVIDIA's current driver offerings are not as mature as they need to be for most users, and that problem has also cropped up with other drivers for other users.
We are concerned about the lack of a 2.2V memory setting as we would have liked some additional headroom with our mid to upper range memory modules. As it stands, we are still able to utilize CAS3 and 1T command rates with the SPP voltage increased to 1.30V with our premium memory selection. In all honesty, the application performance differences between our budget memory modules and the higher performing modules were usually less than 5% in extended testing that showed our Transcend JetRam DDR2-800 or Wintec AMPX DDR2-800 being a perfect budget match for this board with a price around $125 for 2GB.
The overclocking aspects of the board are terrific considering the price point and with the asynchronous memory capability you can really push the FSB while retaining budget priced DDR2-800 memory in the system. This is one area where NVIDIA has an advantage over Intel in this price sector as the P965 boards are generally limited to 400FSB and less than stellar memory performance. We typically found that 4-4-4-12 1T or 4-4-3-10 2T timings at DDR2-800 offered a nice balance between memory price considerations and performance on this board.
We feel like the EVGA 650i Ultra offers a high degree of quality, performance, and support in a package that costs a little under $100. This board is certainly not perfect nor is it designed for everyone but it offers almost the perfect package in an Intel market sector that has not had anything real interesting to talk about for a long time. We are left wondering why NVIDIA chose the silent path to introduce this chipset when it's obvious they really have something interesting to discuss this time around.
This is our first look at a true NVIDIA budget solution for the Intel platform. NVIDIA has done a terrific job combining the 650i SLI SPP and nf430 MCP into a board design that offers extremely competitive performance at a compelling price point. This is the same design philosophy that NVIDIA is using with the 680i LT SLI chipset but we felt like that EVGA board lacked a finishing coat of polish. In some ways we feel the same way about the EVGA 650i Ultra board as well.
Don't get us wrong: we think the performance of the board and the basic features are terrific for an estimated selling price around $95 to $99, especially when looking at other Intel solutions in this price range. However, we firmly believe that a few additions such as memory voltages to 2.2V, CPU VTT / GTL Ref voltage control, Firewire, and maybe a six-layer board design would have placed this board in the exceptional category for those enthusiasts on a budget.
What those extras would have meant in additional cost is something we will never know, but if it only meant a few extra dollars then we firmly believe they would have been well worth it. As it is, we have to judge the board on its own merits against other offerings in the same price range and with that we present it a Silver Editors' Choice Award.
![]() |
We did not experience any major problems with the board during an intense week long test schedule utilizing Windows XP. We did find a few minor issues with nTune, a fan header that is thermally preset to 60C before the fan will operate, and a few overclocking nuances with our quad core CPU due to crosstalk problems on the board. We just started Vista testing on this board and will provide an update in our upcoming roundup article. We have not experienced issues in Vista yet other than immature driver release problems. It appears from our forums and others that NVIDIA's current driver offerings are not as mature as they need to be for most users, and that problem has also cropped up with other drivers for other users.
We are concerned about the lack of a 2.2V memory setting as we would have liked some additional headroom with our mid to upper range memory modules. As it stands, we are still able to utilize CAS3 and 1T command rates with the SPP voltage increased to 1.30V with our premium memory selection. In all honesty, the application performance differences between our budget memory modules and the higher performing modules were usually less than 5% in extended testing that showed our Transcend JetRam DDR2-800 or Wintec AMPX DDR2-800 being a perfect budget match for this board with a price around $125 for 2GB.
The overclocking aspects of the board are terrific considering the price point and with the asynchronous memory capability you can really push the FSB while retaining budget priced DDR2-800 memory in the system. This is one area where NVIDIA has an advantage over Intel in this price sector as the P965 boards are generally limited to 400FSB and less than stellar memory performance. We typically found that 4-4-4-12 1T or 4-4-3-10 2T timings at DDR2-800 offered a nice balance between memory price considerations and performance on this board.
We feel like the EVGA 650i Ultra offers a high degree of quality, performance, and support in a package that costs a little under $100. This board is certainly not perfect nor is it designed for everyone but it offers almost the perfect package in an Intel market sector that has not had anything real interesting to talk about for a long time. We are left wondering why NVIDIA chose the silent path to introduce this chipset when it's obvious they really have something interesting to discuss this time around.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2207 (Wayback Machine).
