MSI P6N SLI Platinum: NVIDIA's 650i Part Two
- Posted in
- Motherboards
Disk Controller Performance
The AnandTech iPeak test is designed to measure "pure" hard disk controller performance, and in this case, we keep the hard drive as consistent as possible while varying the hard drive controller. The idea is to measure the performance of each hard drive controller with the same hard drive.
We played back our raw files that are recorded I/O operations when running a real world benchmark - the entire Winstone 2004 suite. Intel's iPeak utility was then used to play back the trace file of all I/O operations that took place during a single run of Business Winstone 2004 and MCC Winstone 2004. The drive is formatted before each test run and a composite average of three tests on each controller interface is tabulated in order to ensure consistency in the benchmark.
iPeak gives a mean service time in milliseconds; in other words, the average time that each drive took to fulfill each I/O operation. In order to make the data more understandable, we report the scores as an average number of I/O operations per second so that higher scores translate into better performance. This number is meaningless as far as hard disk performance is concerned, as it is just the number of I/O operations completed in a second. However, the scores are useful for comparing "pure" performance of the storage controllers in this case.


The performance patterns hold steady across both Multimedia Content I/O and Business I/O with the SB600 outperforming the Intel ICH7R, Intel ICH8R, and NVIDIA 680i/650i chipsets in our non-Raid tests. The Promise controller on the DFI board is the slowest of all solutions with the Marvell controller on the Intel 975X performing only slightly better. The 680i and 650i MCP chipsets are different but their disk performance in our tests is basically alike. We also ran RAID 0 and RAID 5 tests on each controller with the results being in favor of the 680i MCP by around 2%.
We did not witness any data corruption on our NVIDIA based boards as has been reported on the 680i reference boards, and we consider this problem to be fixed since our P23 BIOS update. We did have data corruption issues with the Gigabyte board when using 1T Command Rate at DDR2-800 with an early F2 beta BIOS but this was solved in the final F3 BIOS. Although our NVIDIA boards generally score lower in these "pure" throughput tests, we find their performance in disk intensive applications is generally better than the other solutions.
Power Consumption

Our power consumption numbers are based on our test setup for this article that consists of the MSI 8800GTX video card, and our boards have C1E/EIST turned off. The 680i leads all boards in power consumption and the 650i SLI is second though on average it still consumes about 7% less power than the 680i at idle and 3% at load. The P965 consumes the least amount of power at idle but around 10% more than the RD600 at load. The 975X still offers a decent level of power conservation compared to the other chipsets even though it is over two years old now.
Overclocking

As we mentioned earlier in the article, the overclocking capability of the MSI board has varied widely with each BIOS release we have tested. This will be disappointing to some users and we expected a little better overclocking capability based upon the quality of the board and its BIOS options. However, like most recent MSI boards we find they have generally implemented very aggressive memory and chipset timings at stock speeds at the expense of overclocking. This is generally true of the MSI P6N SLI Platinum but we have found it overclocks better than most of the MSI boards we have tested recently.
One area we found interesting is the MSI board experienced several FSB holes with the 1.22 BIOS that we witnessed on the 680i reference boards. We did experience the typical FSB hole around 416FSB and hit another one right around 460FSB and 500FSB in the latest BIOS. We also found that during overclocking we had to set our CPU voltages a little higher than on the other boards to attain the same overclocks. We have experienced this before with other MSI boards and it was due to tighter sub-timings in order to improve the performance of the board at stock speeds.
The AnandTech iPeak test is designed to measure "pure" hard disk controller performance, and in this case, we keep the hard drive as consistent as possible while varying the hard drive controller. The idea is to measure the performance of each hard drive controller with the same hard drive.
We played back our raw files that are recorded I/O operations when running a real world benchmark - the entire Winstone 2004 suite. Intel's iPeak utility was then used to play back the trace file of all I/O operations that took place during a single run of Business Winstone 2004 and MCC Winstone 2004. The drive is formatted before each test run and a composite average of three tests on each controller interface is tabulated in order to ensure consistency in the benchmark.
iPeak gives a mean service time in milliseconds; in other words, the average time that each drive took to fulfill each I/O operation. In order to make the data more understandable, we report the scores as an average number of I/O operations per second so that higher scores translate into better performance. This number is meaningless as far as hard disk performance is concerned, as it is just the number of I/O operations completed in a second. However, the scores are useful for comparing "pure" performance of the storage controllers in this case.


The performance patterns hold steady across both Multimedia Content I/O and Business I/O with the SB600 outperforming the Intel ICH7R, Intel ICH8R, and NVIDIA 680i/650i chipsets in our non-Raid tests. The Promise controller on the DFI board is the slowest of all solutions with the Marvell controller on the Intel 975X performing only slightly better. The 680i and 650i MCP chipsets are different but their disk performance in our tests is basically alike. We also ran RAID 0 and RAID 5 tests on each controller with the results being in favor of the 680i MCP by around 2%.
We did not witness any data corruption on our NVIDIA based boards as has been reported on the 680i reference boards, and we consider this problem to be fixed since our P23 BIOS update. We did have data corruption issues with the Gigabyte board when using 1T Command Rate at DDR2-800 with an early F2 beta BIOS but this was solved in the final F3 BIOS. Although our NVIDIA boards generally score lower in these "pure" throughput tests, we find their performance in disk intensive applications is generally better than the other solutions.
Power Consumption

Our power consumption numbers are based on our test setup for this article that consists of the MSI 8800GTX video card, and our boards have C1E/EIST turned off. The 680i leads all boards in power consumption and the 650i SLI is second though on average it still consumes about 7% less power than the 680i at idle and 3% at load. The P965 consumes the least amount of power at idle but around 10% more than the RD600 at load. The 975X still offers a decent level of power conservation compared to the other chipsets even though it is over two years old now.
Overclocking

As we mentioned earlier in the article, the overclocking capability of the MSI board has varied widely with each BIOS release we have tested. This will be disappointing to some users and we expected a little better overclocking capability based upon the quality of the board and its BIOS options. However, like most recent MSI boards we find they have generally implemented very aggressive memory and chipset timings at stock speeds at the expense of overclocking. This is generally true of the MSI P6N SLI Platinum but we have found it overclocks better than most of the MSI boards we have tested recently.
One area we found interesting is the MSI board experienced several FSB holes with the 1.22 BIOS that we witnessed on the 680i reference boards. We did experience the typical FSB hole around 416FSB and hit another one right around 460FSB and 500FSB in the latest BIOS. We also found that during overclocking we had to set our CPU voltages a little higher than on the other boards to attain the same overclocks. We have experienced this before with other MSI boards and it was due to tighter sub-timings in order to improve the performance of the board at stock speeds.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2190 (Wayback Machine).