Archive 1997–2024

Intel P965: MSI P965 Platinum and ECS PX1 Extreme

Media Encoding Performance

Our first test is quite easy: we take our original Office Space DVD and use AnyDVD Ripper to copy the full DVD to the hard drive without compression, thus providing an almost exact duplicate of the DVD. We then fire up Nero Recode 2, select our Office Space copy on the hard drive, and perform a shrink operation to allow the entire movie along with extras to fit on a single 4.5GB DVD disc. We left all options on their defaults except we checked off the advanced analysis option. The scores reported include the full encoding process and are represented in minutes and seconds, with lower numbers providing better performance.

Media Encoding Performance - Nero Recode 2

The MSI P965 ties the Gigabyte and ASUS boards in this very demanding test while the ECS board once again trails the pack due to its memory performance issues. The 975X and NVIDIA 570SLI lag slightly behind in this test where the CPU and storage subsystems are stressed.

Audio Encoding Performance

While the media encoding prowess of the P965 boards was superb in our initial media encoding testing, we wanted to see how they faired on the audio side. Our audio test suite consists of Exact Audio Copy v095.b4 and LAME 3.98a3. We utilize the INXS Greatest Hits CD that contains 16 tracks totaling 606MB of one time '80s hits.

We set up EAC for variable bit rate encoding, burst mode for extraction, use external program for compression, and to start the external compressor upon extraction (EAC will read the next track while LAME is working on the previous track, thus removing a potential bottleneck with the optical drive). We also set the number of active threads to two to ensure both cores are active during testing. The results are presented in minutes/seconds for the encoding process, with lower numbers being better.

Audio Encoding Performance - LAME 3.98a3

As in the media encoding section, the more intensive CPU and storage system tests seem to favor the P965 over the i975X/NV570SLI when running at the same memory timings. Once again, the MSI P965 Platinum shows surprising strength at stock speeds by finishing in a first place tie with our other top boards. We are tired of repeating this but our ECS board finishes near last due to memory timings, but its results are still acceptable.

File Compression Performance

In order to save space on our hard drives and ensure we had another CPU crunching utility, we will be reporting our file compression results with the latest version of WinRAR that fully supports multi-treaded operations and should be of particular interest for those users with dual core or multi-processor systems. Our series of file compression tests utilizes WinRAR 3.61 to compress our test folder that contains 444 files, ten subfolders, and 602MB worth of data. All default settings are utilized in WinRAR along with our hard drive being defragmented before each test.

File Compression Performance - WinRAR 3.61

Once again the MSI board shares first place honors. The margins are extremely close between our P965 boards just reiterating the fact that boards based on the same chipset are going to offer the same performance, even with the ECS having reduced memory performance. The 975X and 570SLI boards trail slightly but the differences are minimal.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2128 (Wayback Machine).