Archive 1997–2024

SMB NAS Roundup

Selecting the contenders

We selected the devices based primarily on price and configuration. There are many more NAS products on the market, but we had to keep it down to a reasonable number for the sake of brevity. All of the devices are 4-disk units, and range from $600-1100, with the most expensive unit being the Hammer Z-Box, which is really an entry-level SAN product.

Below is a list of the devices included in this roundup:
  1. Hammer Z-Box
  2. LaCie Ethernet Disk 1TB
  3. Intel SS4000-E
  4. Thecus N4100
  5. QNAP TS401-T
  6. Infrant NV+
  7. Buffalo TeraStation
Seagate was gracious enough to provide us with several SATA2 drives so we could ensure all devices were using the same type of drive. The only exception was LaCie, as it comes with its own internal drives, but more on that later.

Test Configuration

To test the devices we used two benchmarks: IOMeter, and what we like to call "DOSBench". The IOMeter configuration file can be found here, and we tested transfer sizes from 8K to 512K. The DOSBench application uses a tool from the Windows 2000 resource kit (Timethis). How DOSBench works is that we create a RamDisk and put some data files on it. We then run a batch file which copies files from the RamDisk to the NAS device, and back again. Using Timethis we record the time each copy routine takes and then calculate the transfer rate.

Client Configuration:
Windows XP
2GB Memory
Opteron 180
NetGear GS605 5-port switch
NVIDIA nForce Network Card.

NAS Configuration

We tested each device in its default configuration. We decided not use Jumbo frames, as most users won't have the necessary infrastructure required to support it.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2127 (Wayback Machine).