AcomData E5 320GB External Desktop Storage: Slap on another
- Posted in
- Storage
WinBench 99
We have extended our WinBench 99 portion of our benchmarks to include not only the Disk Transfer Rate tests, but also a handful of other disk performance related tests, which include Disk Access Time, CPU Utilization, Disk Playback/Bus, Disk Playback/HE, and Disk Playback/Removable Media. As we present our results, we will explain how each test is relevant in our methodology.Disk Transfer Rate
In the past, we only provided the beginning and ending transfer rates, which don't really show the performance of the entire disk because there is so much more in between, on which we are not reporting. Our new method includes a graph.We repeated this test 3 times to verify the results. During the test, the transfer rate stays at around 34MB/sec throughout except for the region between the 0-30GB range and the 40-65GB range. This test involves a continuous read from the beginning to the end of the entire capacity of the disk to show the consistency in transfer rates over the course of the disk.
When the E5 is connected over FireWire 400, we see much more constant transfer rates at around 39MB/sec with no random shifts in these transfer rates. This could have a lot to do with the USB interface's dependence on the CPU, while the FireWire standard is a peer-to-peer interface and does not require a "middle-man".
Disk Access Time
The average disk access time for the 320GB Caviar encased in AcomData's E5 casing was 13.2ms. Compare this to the 8.9ms access time with the 320GB Caviar installed into a system on the IDE interface and it seems sluggish, but only as much as legacy disk drives.Disk CPU Utilization
WinBench 99 reports a 79.3% CPU load while transferring at 4MB/sec with the USB interface and 76.4% on the FireWire 400 interface. Ouch! Though the USB interface relies on the CPU for control, we did not expect the CPU load to be that much, and the results of CPU load for the FireWire 400 interface surprised us even more, since it is peer-to-peer. We don't want to conclude that the performance of this drive is mediocre, since we have not looked at other drives yet. So, we will wait until we can test another external device to make any assumptions on this topic.Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1774 (Wayback Machine).

