Archive 1997–2024

SFF Roundup, Socket 939 Systems

Gaming Benchmarks

We have chosen two of the big gaming titles for our gaming benchmarks. All tests were done at 1024x768 both with and without 4xAA. 8xAF was enabled in both cases, as it did not impact performance much. We used the standard Demo1 for Doom 3 and the City_17_12 and Canals_08 levels within Half-life 2. (We're running the revision 7 version of the timedemo engine, in case you were wondering.) The levels chosen for HL2 tend to stress the CPU and system rather than just the GPU, so we felt that they were the most useful in terms of benchmarks.

Doom 3 Performance

Doom 3 Performance

Half-life 2 Performance

Half-Life 2 Performance

Half-life 2 Performance

Half-life 2 Performance

Starting with Doom 3, all of the systems are close enough together to basically call it a tie... with the exception of the SN25P. Something has changed performance quite a bit since our initial review of the SN25P, as the results with the latest BIOS are about 5% slower in most tests. That's almost a full CPU bin downgrade, though the scores are mostly in line with the other systems now. If the older scores can be reached without compromising stability, we'd like to see an updated BIOS that brings back former performance levels while also offering the new features of the latest BIOS. Consider the 4xAA Doom 3 test something of a reality check: if you don't have a fast enough graphics card and you want all the eye candy, the difference in performance between most systems is very small.

Half-Life 2 is less GPU limited than Doom 3, so the performance varies more among the contenders. The 330P was tied for fastest at running Doom 3, but it ranks near the bottom of the 939 units in HL2. Shuttle's SN25P is the reverse, going from the slowest in Doom 3 to one of the fastest in HL2. Meanwhile, the SN95G5 really has problems with the Canals level with 4xAA for whatever reason, but performs well on the City 17 level.

Picking an overall gaming winner is difficult, given the variations among the units, but the margin between slowest and fastest is only 6% (throwing out the anomalous 4xAA Canals score from the SN95G5). If the System Control utility has as much of an impact as we suspect, the 330P could actually move into undisputed first place without the utility running, so hopefully, Biostar can address that desire.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1754 (Wayback Machine).