Archive 1997–2024

Intel NUC11TNBi5 and Akasa Newton TN Fanless Case Review: Silencing the Tiger

System Performance: Multi-Tasking

One of the key drivers of advancements in computing systems is multi-tasking. On mobile devices, this is quite lightweight - cases such as background email checks while the user is playing a mobile game are quite common. Towards optimizing user experience in those types of scenarios, mobile SoC manufacturers started integrating heterogeneous CPU cores - some with high performance for demanding workloads, while others were frugal in terms of both power consumption / die area and performance. This trend is now slowly making its way into the desktop PC space.

Multi-tasking in typical PC usage is much more demanding compared to phones and tablets. Desktop OSes allow users to launch and utilize a large number of demanding programs simultaneously. Responsiveness is dictated largely by the OS scheduler allowing different tasks to move to the background. Intel's Alder Lake processors work closely with the Windows 11 thread scheduler to optimize performance in these cases. Keeping these aspects in mind, the evaluation of multi-tasking performance is an interesting subject to tackle.

We have augmented our systems benchmarking suite to quantitatively analyze the multi-tasking performance of various platforms. The evaluation involves triggering a VLC transcoding task to transform 1716 3840x1714 frames encoded as a 24fps AVC video (Blender Project's 'Tears of Steel' 4K version) into a 1080p HEVC version in a loop. VLC internally uses the x265 encoder, and the settings are configured to allow the CPU usage to be saturated across all cores. The transcoding rate is monitored continuously. One complete transcoding pass is allowed to complete before starting the first multi-tasking workload - the PCMark 10 Extended bench suite. A comparative view of the PCMark 10 scores for various scenarios is presented in the graphs below. Also available for concurrent viewing are scores in the normal case where the benchmark was processed without any concurrent load, and a graph presenting the loss in performance.

UL PCMark 10 Load Testing - Digital Content Creation Scores

UL PCMark 10 Load Testing - Productivity Scores

UL PCMark 10 Load Testing - Essentials Scores

UL PCMark 10 Load Testing - Gaming Scores

UL PCMark 10 Load Testing - Overall Scores

Except for the gaming workload which is pretty much unaffected by the CPU loading, the sheer number of cores in the Renoir-based systems help it in salvaging good scores in the presence of concurrent loading.

Following the completion of the PCMark 10 benchmark, a short delay is introduced prior to the processing of Principled Technologies WebXPRT4 on MS Edge. Similar to the PCMark 10 results presentation, the graph below show the scores recorded with the transcoding load active. Available for comparison are the dedicated CPU power scores and a measure of the performance loss.

Principled Technologies WebXPRT4 Load Testing Scores (MS Edge)

The Tiger Lake-U systems are the top performers here, both in terms of raw scores and minizing performance loss.

The final workload tested as part of the multitasking evaluation routine is CINEBENCH R23.

3D Rendering - CINEBENCH R23 Load Testing - Single Thread Score

3D Rendering - CINEBENCH R23 Load Testing - Multiple Thread Score

The large number of cores in the Renoir systems allow it to shuffle around the tasks in such a way that the performance loss for rendering workloads is minimized.

After the completion of all the workloads, we let the transcoding routine run to completion. The monitored transcoding rate throughout the above evaluation routine (in terms of frames per second) for select systems are tabulated below.

VLC Transcoding Rate (Multi-Tasking Test) - Frames per Second
  Enc. Pass #1 PCMark 10 WebXPRT4 Cinebench Enc. Pass #2
ASRock 4X4 BOX-4800U
(Ryzen 7 4800U)
1.6366 1.5167 1.4080 1.5505 1.6073
Intel NUC11TNBi5 (Akasa Newton TN)
(Core i5-1135G7)
0.8662 0.7773 0.7275 0.7773 0.8722
ASRock NUC BOX-1165G7
(Core i7-1165G7)
0.8409 0.8004 0.7230 0.7534 0.8854

The transcoding rates in different systems drop down with simultaneous loading, as expected. The key numbers to note in the above table are the first and second encoding passes for the Newton build. With the numbers actually showing a slight advantage for the second pass, it is clear that there is no throttling at play for this particular workload and duration.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/17502/intel-nuc11tnbi5-and-akasa-newton-tn-fanless-case-review-silencing-the-tiger (Wayback Machine).