Archive 1997–2024

Price Guides August 2005: Motherboards

Intel Motherboards

Although Intel does not quite have the same rich selection in motherboard manufacturers and products, there are some pitfalls you need to watch out for when buying current generation Intel hardware. Let's look at the cost of two comparable systems with the costs of hardware in August 2005 prices:

Athlon 64 X2 3800+ $394
2x512MB PC-3200 $86
Chaintech VNF4 Ultra $82
Total: $562

Pentium D 820 $235
2x512MB PC2-4200 $90
MSI 945P Neo-F $125
Total: $450

So technically, Intel has the much cheaper dual system right now. Unfortunately, if you value gaming performance at all, the Intel system is not the way to go. In fact, in Anand's recent benchmarks the Athlon 64 X2 3800+ pretty much swept the Pentium D 830 in every benchmark except office productivity (and even then that was in a synthetic benchmark). If we were to factor the price of the chips above to feature the Pentium D 830 instead of the X2 3800+, the Intel system would still come out ahead in price, but not by much. We still like the Pentium D, particularly for a work machine where you're expected to chug away in Outlook rather than play Doom3, but for the average workstation AMD is looking more and more attractive.

With Intel, the only real choices on a motherboard right now are 955X or 945G/P. The 955X boards are great, but insanely expensive. If you plan to go the way of cheap dual core (the only advantage Intel has right now), you don't want a 955X motherboard. On a mildly related note, ASUS's P5WD2 Premium WiFi-TV is the only motherboard in the last 5 years that managed to jump an extra $50 less than two months after its debut. In fact, 955X motherboards everywhere seem to be drying up and increasing in price. We sure aren't recommending them, so the initial runs must have been very low quantity to dry up by now.

Meanwhile Intel's workhorse chipset, 945P, quietly continues to introduce new and better priced models. Once again MSI has the best prices this week with the exception of a few Intel branded and Gigabyte models. The Gigabyte GA-8I945P-G [RTPE: GA-8I945P-G], MSI Neo-F [RTPE: MS-7176-020] and Intel D945PSNLK [RTPE: D945PSNLK] all cary about the same feature set, but the Gigabyte board saves you an extra $10 over the MSI alternative so we will have to recommend them again this week.

Prices are unfortunately stagnant on the 945P arena. MSI's 945P Platinum [RTPE: MS-7176-010] has a $25 mail-in-rebate, but the only advantage the Platinum board has over the non-Platinum board is the 1394/Firewire support; and you'll still have to pay $153 to get the board out the door. Your money is better spent elsewhere in our opinion.

We said above that gaming performance means you'll really want an Athlon X2 instead of a Pentium D. If you don't care about gaming, there's a good chance you don't care about high performance graphics. The only real difference between the 945P and 945G is the presence or lack of integrated graphics. While the GMA950 graphics aren't particularly fast in 3D applications, business users probably won't care. Most of the cheapest 945G boards carry the Intel name, and there are many micro-ATX designs if that interests you. We'd go with the MSI 945G Neo-F i945G [RTPE: MS-7176-040], though if you want Firewire the Gigabyte 945G GA-8I945G Pro [RTPE: GA-8I945G]is $10 more.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1749 (Wayback Machine).