Archive 1997–2024

Workstation Graphics: AGP Cross Section 2004


Shader Analysis

To open this section, we would first like to start by stating that we wish we could have found a suitable benchmark to test GLSL performance in a similar way that Shadermark manages to test HLSL performance. OpenGL fragment shading performance under which we ran the demos on the Wildcat Realizm part is much higher than its DirectX pixel shading performance under Shadermark. In fact, even in playing with ATI's own Rendermonkey, it was apparent that the 3Dlabs card handled GLSL shaders better than the FireGL X3. Since OpenGL is the language of the workstation, it makes sense that the workstation is only where 3Dlabs would focus its efforts first, while ATI's consumer oriented approach would lend it the clear upper hand in DirectX HLSL benchmarks like Shadermark.

But DirectX and HLSL is still a very relevant test and is supported on all these cards. Of note is the fact that Shadermark would not run PS 3.0 code on the Wildcat Realizm. Shadermark chose to use the PS 2.0a path, which supports a wider range of features than the PS 2.0b path used for both of the ATI cards. Shadermark has been known to be very picky about code paths that it runs, and it's possible that there is an issue with the fact that this 3Dlabs part is simply not on the Shadermark map. But part of the point of HLSL is that the code should still run with no problems. We did get the option of creating an A2R10G10B10 hardware device on the Wildcat Realizm in shadermark where no other card presented such a feature. But let's take a look at what the numbers have to say.

 Shadermark v2.1 Performance Chart
   GeForce 6800U  Quadro FX 4000  Radeon X850XT  FireGL X3-256  Realizm 200
shader 2 893 596 996 731 41
shader 3 736 493 735 531 28
shader 4 737 493 732 531 28
shader 5 669 448 608 438 16
shader 6 680 467 735 530 28
shader 7 631 417 654 485 23
shader 8 383 255 406 301 11
shader 9 894 630 1263 977 55
shader 10 807 553 819 617 43
shader 11 680 467 694 509 27
shader 12 446 319 263 186 13
shader 13 383 276 361 252 13
shader 14 446 316 399 280 18
shader 15 328 244 285 206 21
shader 16 314 224 336 244 8
shader 17 425 309 429 315 8
shader 18 56 39 40 30 2
shader 19 180 134 139 99 6
shader 20 57 41 47 33 3
shader 21 90 63 - - -
shader 22 119 96 204 154 14
shader 23 133 106 - - 15
shader 24 80 67 143 108 118
shader 25 97 69 118 86 6
shader 26 93 67 123 89 6

Not surprisingly, the consumer level parts are the top performers here. The Quadro FX 4000 and FireGL X3-256 don't do a bad job of keeping up with their desktop counterparts. However, the Wildcat Realizm 200 puts in a very poor showing. In addition to this, the Realizm didn't render many of the shaders correctly. Granted, the Microsoft reference rasterizer does not create correct images, but they are close in most cases. Shadermark generates MSE (mean squared error) data for screenshots taken and compared against reference images. Both ATI and NVIDIA hit between 0.5 and 1 in most tests. There is not a single shader rendered on the Wildcat Realizm 200 with an MSE of less than about 2.5. Most shaders show very clear image quality issues.

With the image quality of Wildcat Realizm in Doom 3 and Half-Life 2 being dead on with the other cards, and performance under Half-Life 2 not being as bad as we expected, we have to wonder how much of the issues with Shadermark would translate into actual applications. And by applications, we mean any application that allows the creation and/or visualization of HLSL or GLSL shaders. DCC workstation users are becoming more and more involved in the process of creating and designing complex shader effects. In order to maintain a firm position in the future of DCC workflow, 3Dlabs will need to assure smooth, accurate support of HLSL, no matter what the application running the code.

We will continue to evaluate programs for benchmarking GLSL performance. Through observation, the NVIDIA and 3Dlabs parts have an advantage over the ATI parts in GLSL performance. Unfortunately, we don't have any quantitative tests to bring to the table at this time.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1575 (Wayback Machine).