Photosmart M307: HP's Newest is Put to the Test
- Posted in
- Digital Camera
General Image Quality
For these pictures, the camera was reset to its factory default setting. Then, it was set to its highest quality recording setting. The pictures were then taken in Auto mode unless stated otherwise. Portrait-style images have been rotated using Irfanview's "lossless operations". Click on a thumbnail to view the full-size image. The crops below the thumbnails are 100%. All images are in sRGB color space. ![]() ISO 100, 1/1100, f/4.8 Click to enlarge. |
![]() ISO 100, 1/500, f/4.8 Click to enlarge. |
![]() ISO 100, 1/1250, f/4.8 Click to enlarge. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() ISO 100, 1/310, f/4.9 Click to enlarge. |
![]() ISO 100, 1/160, f/7.8 Click to enlarge. |
![]() ISO 100, 1/400, f/4.8 (Macro) Click to enlarge. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
In the first 4 samples above, we have highlighted what we think are some important image quality problems. Firstly, in several images, we spotted "jaggies" along diagonal lines. These "jaggies" are a result of the M307's over-sharpening process. In the second sample, we cropped out a portion of the image that displays moiré, which is a more common problem with "lower" resolution cameras. In the third sample, we wanted to point out something that we feel is the most significant weak point of the M307 - loss of detail. In many of the images taken with this camera, in the place of detail, we noticed this fuzzy, muddy appearance. This image also displays the rather small dynamic range of the camera. In the fourth sample, we are looking at more detail loss, but this time, it is concentrated in shadow areas. Objects with plenty of light retain a moderate amount of detail. However, there is a dramatic loss of detail for objects in the shade.
Things look a lot better in samples 5 and 6. In both pictures, the image quality looks pretty decent overall. In the last shot, the M307 proves it can take sharp macro pictures. In the end though, we aren't very impressed with the M307's image quality. The biggest problems are over-sharpening, moiré, loss of detail in shadows, and high noise. We were especially surprised to see so much noise at the lowest ISO setting.
Low Light

ISO 100, 2 sec, f/4.7
Click to enlarge.

In this two-second exposure, the image is still quite noisy for ISO 100. Unfortunately, the camera limits the shutter speed to a maximum of two seconds so there is no possibility of performing longer exposures. Also, throughout the image, we spotted several stuck pixels.
Movie Mode

(320x240, 30 fps)
Click to view.
As the sample above demonstrates, although 30 fps is great to have, a video clip at 320x240 is hard to get excited about. In addition to the video's noisy appearance, we were also disappointed with the audio quality. There is a constant hissing sound that can be heard during playback. Although we weren't expecting much from the video mode on this camera, the unbearable audio and low resolution renders its functionality nearly useless.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1554 (Wayback Machine).











