Archive 1997–2024

The OpenPOWER Saga Continues: Can You Get POWER Inside 1U?

Java Performance

The SPECjbb 2015 benchmark has "a usage model based on a world-wide supermarket company with an IT infrastructure that handles a mix of point-of-sale requests, online purchases, and data-mining operations." It uses the latest Java 7 features and makes use of XML, compressed communications, and messaging with security.

We tested with four groups of transaction injectors and backends. The reason why we use the "Multi JVM" test is that it is more realistic: multiple VMs on a server is a very common practice.

The Java version was OpenJDK 1.8.0_91. We applied relatively basic tuning to mimic real-world use, while aiming to fit everything inside a server with 128 GB of RAM:

"-server -Xmx24G -Xms24G -Xmn16G -XX:+AlwaysPreTouch -XX:+UseLargePages"

The graph below shows the maximum throughput numbers for our MultiJVM SPECJbb test.

SPECJBB 2015-Multi Max-jOPS

The Critical-jOPS metric is a throughput metric under a response-time constraint.

The 8-core Tyan POWER8 server offers about 72% of the performance of the 10-core IBM S812LC. That is not too bad as the latter not only has 20% more cores, but the chip can also boost 16% higher. In total, the IBM POWER8 CPU inside the 2U S812LC offers about 45% greater processing power ("35 GHz" vs "24 GHz") and delivers about 40% better performance. So compared to the S812LC, the 1U Tyan delivers very decent performance.

But Intel is the one to beat. And by caging the POWER8 inside a 1U, performance has dropped below the power sipping (90W TDP!) Xeon E5-2640v4.

SPECJBB 2013-Multi Critical-jOPS

Meanwhile our next benchmark is a good reminder that OpenJDK 8's performance is not optimal for the POWER8. The IBM JDK (More details here) does not offer much better throughput, unless you start tuning frantically. However, it does increase the most important score, critical-jOPS, with reasonable tuning.

However, while the more powerful 2U POWER8 can still keep up with Intel's best and most expensive (only 9% slower), the frequency capped CPU inside the Tyan 1U fails to impress as it trails the less expensive and less power hungry Xeon E5-2640 v4 by a large margin.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/10923/openpower-saga-tyans-1u-power8-gt75 (Wayback Machine).