QNAP TS-451+ SOHO NAS Review
Multi-Client CIFS Performance for Professional Workloads
NAS units used in SMBs / SMEs need to provide good performance under heavy load from multiple clients. The SPEC SFS 2014 benchmark uses real-life workloads (just like Intel NASPT), but makes it easier for users to understand the benchmark results. This is achieved by using the concept of business metrics. Given a particular NAS unit, how many concurrently accessed databases can reside in it? How many IP cameras or video streams can be simultaneously recorded? To determine this metric, each load point is associated with a target required op rate. If the NAS under test doesn't meet that op rate, it is deemed as an 'invalid run'. SPEC requires all published benchmarks to follow certain strict rules - such as presented results having no invalid runs for at least 10 load points. Unfortunately, small-scale NAS systems with 7200 RPM drives can't meet these requirements, Hence, we can't officially publish SPEC SFS 2014 benchmark results for the evaluation of the QNAP TS-451+.
Using a popular filer benchmarking program, we did play back multi-client real-world professional workload access traces on the NAS using up to 10 Windows 7 VMs. However, failing to meet the required op rate criteria at a particular load point made us stop the testing a couple of load points down the road. The QNAP TS-451+ with four 7200 RPM hard drives in RAID-5 can support recording of 10 or more video streams, 5 or less databases, 4 or less software builds and 2 or less virtual desktops.
Database Operations
The Database Operations workload seems to get / doesn't seem to get acceptable performance for up to 5 clients.The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here


Software Builds
The Software Builds workload seems to get / doesn't seem to get acceptable performance for up to 4 clients.The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here


Video Recording
The Video Recording workload seems to get / doesn't seem to get acceptable performance for up to 10 clients.The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here


Virtual Desktops
The Virtual Desktops workload seems to get / doesn't seem to get acceptable performance for up to 2 clients.The detailed metrics from our trace playback are available here


Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/9749/qnap-ts451-soho-nas-review (Wayback Machine).