Archive 1997–2024

Western Digital My Cloud DL4100 Business NAS Review

Multi-Client iSCSI Evaluation

As virtualization becomes more and more popular even in home / power user settings, the importance of the iSCSI feature set of any COTS NAS can't be overstated. Starting with our ioSafe 1513+ review, we have started devoting a separate section (in the reviews of NAS units targeting SMBs and SMEs) to the evaluation of iSCSI performance. NAS vendors have multiple options when it comes to implementing iSCSI LUNs. By far, the most common and simplest method is in the form of regular files. Western Digital adopts that method too. WD also allows multiple initiators to connect to a single iSCSI target.

We evaluated the performance of the WD My Cloud DL4100 with file-based LUNs. In the first case, we configured a single LUN and had multiple initiators from different machines connect to it. In the second case, we created one LUN/target for each initiator to connect to. The standard IOMeter benchmarks that we used for multi-client CIFS evaluation were utilized for iSCSI evaluation also. The main difference to note is that the CIFS evaluation was performed on a mounted network share, while the iSCSI evaluation was done on a 'clean physical disk' (from the viewpoint of the virtual machine).

Performance Numbers

The four IOMeter traces were run on the physical disk manifested by mapping the iSCSI target on each VM. The benchmarking started with one VM accessing the NAS. The number of VMs simultaneously playing out the trace was incremented one by one till we had all 25 VMs in the fray. Detailed listings of the IOMeter benchmark numbers (including IOPS and maximum response times) for each configuration are linked below:

WD My Cloud DL4100 - Single LUN (Regular File) - Multi-Client Performance - 100% Sequential Reads

 

WD My Cloud DL4100 - Single LUN (Regular File) - Multi-Client Performance - Max Throughput - 50% Reads

 

WD My Cloud DL4100 - Single LUN (Regular File) - Multi-Client Performance - Random 8K - 70% Reads

 

WD My Cloud DL4100 - Single LUN (Regular File) - Multi-Client Performance - Real Life - 65% Reads

The performance issues we encountered in the single-client iSCSI benchmarks are evident here also. The other 4-bay NAS units we have put through these tests (the Seagate NAS Pro 4-bay as well as the Synology DS415+) exhibit better numbers as well as consistency compared to the WD My Cloud DL4100.

Towards the end of the iSCSI testing process, we ran a script on the clients' side to disconnect the iSCSI targets one by one, while refreshing the My Cloud DL4100's web UI's iSCSI page at the same time. During this process, the unit froze up completely - the web UI wasn't reachable, the LCD navigation froze and a SSH connection was refused - there was no way out but to yank out the power and restart the unit. Unfortunately, the logs reported only a power failure and this was not a repeatable issue. In addition to general performance improvements, it appears that the My Cloud OS could do with stability QA also.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/9037/western-digital-my-cloud-dl4100-business-nas-review (Wayback Machine).