Archive 1997–2024

Western Digital My Cloud DL4100 Business NAS Review

Single Client Performance - CIFS & iSCSI on Windows

The single client CIFS and iSCSI performance of the WD My Cloud DL4100 was evaluated on the Windows platforms using Intel NASPT and our standard robocopy benchmark. This was run from one of the virtual machines in our NAS testbed. All data for the robocopy benchmark on the client side was put in a RAM disk (created using OSFMount) to ensure that the client's storage system shortcomings wouldn't affect the benchmark results. It must be noted that all the shares / iSCSI LUNs are created in a RAID-5 volume. One of the interesting aspects of the My Cloud OS is the support for SMB 3.0. Amongst the NAS units that we have evaluated, this is the only OS with support for the latest SMB version other than QNAP's QTS 4.x. SMB 3.0 was evaluated using a Windows 8 VM. It obviously provides better performance compared to SMB 2.0 (Windows 7 doesn't support SMB 3.0).

HD Video Playback - CIFS

2x HD Playback - CIFS

4x HD Playback - CIFS

HD Video Record - CIFS

HD Playback and Record - CIFS

Content Creation - CIFS

Office Productivity - CIFS

File Copy to NAS - CIFS

File Copy from NAS - CIFS

Dir Copy to NAS - CIFS

Dir Copy from NAS - CIFS

Photo Album - CIFS

robocopy (Write to NAS) - CIFS

robocopy (Read from NAS) - CIFS

If the SMB 3.0 results are ignored, we find that the WD My Cloud DL4100 is consistently bettered by either the Synology DS415+ (based on a faster Rangeley SoC) or the QNAP TS-451 (based on a higher-clocked Bay Trail Celeron). In addition, Synology's DSM and QNAP's QTS are much more mature compared to the My Cloud OS.

We created a 250 GB iSCSI LUN / target and mapped it on to a Windows VM in our testbed. The same NASPT benchmarks were run and the results are presented below. The observations we had in the CIFS subsection above hold true here too.

HD Video Playback - iSCSI

2x HD Playback - iSCSI

4x HD Playback - iSCSI

HD Video Record - iSCSI

HD Playback and Record - iSCSI

Content Creation - iSCSI

Office Productivity - iSCSI

File Copy to NAS - iSCSI

File Copy from NAS - iSCSI

Dir Copy to NAS - iSCSI

Dir Copy from NAS - iSCSI

Photo Album - iSCSI

robocopy (Write to NAS) - iSCSI

robocopy (Read from NAS) - iSCSI

The iSCSI implementation in the My Cloud OS has lot of scope for improvement. In certain workloads, even the ARM-based LenovoEMC ix4-300d manages to score better numbers. Other than that, the behavior of the performance numbers track what was observed for the CIFS benchmarks.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/9037/western-digital-my-cloud-dl4100-business-nas-review (Wayback Machine).