Archive 1997–2024

Synology DS2015xs Review: An ARM-based 10G NAS

Miscellaneous Aspects and Final Words

In order to keep testing consistent across all 8-bay units, we performed all our expansion / rebuild testing as well as power consumption evaluation with the unit configured in RAID-5. The disks used for benchmarking (OCZ Vector 4 SSDs) were also used in this section. The table below presents the average power consumption of the unit as well as time taken for various RAID-related activities.

Synology DS2015xs RAID Expansion and Rebuild / Power Consumption
Activity Duration (HH:MM:SS) Avg. Power (W)
Single Disk Init 00:01:00 18.64 W
JBOD to RAID-1 Migration 00:19:14 20.91 W
RAID-1 (2D) to RAID-5 (3D) Migration 00:25:07 23.95 W
RAID-5 (3D) to RAID-5 (4D) Expansion 00:23:48 26.92 W
RAID-5 (4D) to RAID-5 (5D) Expansion 00:24:19 29.86 W
RAID-5 (5D) to RAID-5 (6D) Expansion 00:24:20 32.82 W
RAID-5 (6D) to RAID-5 (7D) Expansion 00:22:49 35.8 W
RAID-5 (7D) to RAID-5 (8D) Expansion 00:20:03 38.79 W
RAID-5 (8D) Rebuild 00:13:12 32.77 W

We don't have any comparison graphs for RAID rebuild duration / power consumption since other 8-bay units were subject to RAID operations with 4 TB hard drives. The usage of 120 GB SSDs prevents us from making any concrete conclusions about the efficiency of Synology's expansion, migration and rebuild operations.

Concluding Remarks

Coming to the business end of the review, it is clear that the presence of two 10G ports enables the DS2015xs to achieve high transfer rates. Compared to the last 10G desktop NAS we evaluated (based on an Intel Xeon platform), the power consumption is much lower At $1400, the DS2015xs is affordably priced, considering the 10G features built into it. DSM's business-oriented features (very important for the DS2015xs's target market) are stable and industry-leading.

The above advantages aside, there are certain areas of concern / scope for improvement: Synology needs to supply a way to test the network performance (provide an optimized iPerf package) isolated from the storage subsystem. The SoC vendor, Annapurna Labs is in the process of being purchased by Amazon. It is not clear what effect that would have on the DS2015xs's successors. It is likely that other ARM server vendors might want to make a play for future products in the lineup.

It is impossible not to conclude this review without a car analogy for the DS2015xs. The presence of dual 10G ports and eight native SATA III ports might delude consumers into thinking that they are purchasing a Ferrari. Unfortunately, consumers only get a souped up Volkswagen engine inside. That said, with tempered expectations, the $1400 Synology DS2015xs can fulfill the role of a cost-effective power-efficient high performance NAS.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/8985/synology-ds2015xs-review-an-armbased-10g-nas (Wayback Machine).